That is fair, but also there is a difference between showing up in August and showing up in January. August, you still practice all of fall leading up to the season. January you are coming from HS to College, in the middle of the season, with no idea how the team plays together/runs its sets/ practices. There is a big difference in their arrival date. Now if he had shown up a few days before the bball season started, that would be a better argument.
Again, not the same but similar.