A month after going to Belize we went to Maui for My wife's work sales event. We went a few days early and did an Airbnb in Kihei. Maui was lovely buy just too many people for my taste. People on the beach, traffic, long waits for every resturaunt, etc. Later, when the sales conference started, we stayed at the Ritz Carlton Maui and all of those concerns went away but I would never pay that much to stay at a hotel.
So in summary, I'm happy we got to go but a big part of my enjoyment is lack of people. When we go to Isla Majures, we stay in a house with its own pool and most of the resturaunts are not busy on the south side of the island.