Question for Iowa fans

[Statefan10]

Because Purdy was much better than Martinez last year, not just barely better

We could also bring up the fact that Brock Purdy played in two less games than Adrian Martinez. Lol

 

[CyTwins]

We could also bring up the fact that Brock Purdy played in two less games than Adrian Martinez. Lol

And Purdy didn't play in the Big Ten West. I'm still giving Martinez the nod though. Barely

 

[Statefan10]

And Purdy didn't play in the Big Ten West. I'm still giving Martinez the nod though. Barely

Or you could go off the fact that Martinez went 4-7 last year, while Brock went 7-2.. I don't know though. Lol there's just not enough information.

 

[CyTwins]

Or you could go off the fact that Martinez went 4-7 last year, while Brock went 7-2.. I don't know though. Lol there's just not enough information.

Nebraska is their rival so of course they're going to defend their QB

 

[Statefan10]

Nebraska is their rival so of course they're going to defend their QB

I mean if that's what he actually thought then props to him.. If you add in the rest of the facts and not just compare the stats, it's definitely Purdy.

 

[Cat Stevens]

lol....cherry picking stats is SOP around here!!!

dude, you have gotten even worse

 

[Cat Stevens]

I barely gave the nod to Martinez last year, obviously this year Purdy is doing much better. I don't understand how that can be so scandalous.

that you were wrong then and you are now trying to pretend it wasn’t just you being a pathetic big 10 homer

 

[CyCloned]

I read Nate Stanley's record vs ranked teams is extremely poor.

~ And Iowa hasn't beat a ranked team on the road since 2015

~ This includes several seasons without Ohio St, Michigan, Mich State, or Penn St on the schedule at various times

With the Big10 they have probably had seasons where they didn't play a ranked team on the road.

 

[dexterhawk]

3

The Michigan Cyclones?

 

[dexterhawk]

The hok jealousy is palpable.

Jealous of what? A worse record and a L head to head?

 

[stevefrench]

How are all of you in the ISR forum not bored of these arguments yet?

 

[GTO]

Jealous of what? A worse record and a L head to head?

Better quarterback and national attention for our coach and QB. Nobody is talking about Captain Kirk or Fat Stanley last year or this year (outside of B1G homers).

 

[GTO]

How are all of you in the ISR forum not bored of these arguments yet?

No.

 

[Gonzo]

Not sure what is more pathetic. The hoks that have lived on this site for a decade with one username or the hot take trolls with like 10 different handles. They are much more similar than they like to think.

Us decade-long, one-handle hoks are way, way more pathetic.

Kind of insulted that you even had to raise the question.

 

[Acylum]

lol....cherry picking stats is SOP around here!!!

If it bothers you so much there’s a simple solution.

 

[dexterhawk]

If it bothers you so much there’s a simple solution.

Doesn't bother me...I just go with the flow.

 

[CyTwins]

I barely gave the nod to Martinez last year, obviously this year Purdy is doing much better. I don't understand how that can be so scandalous.

Bump to laugh at you

 

[CyTwins]

Any good posters on HR I can search on their hot takes about Purdy?

 

[CyTwins]

 

[CyTwins]

Man there are some hot takes in this thread but yeah it appears Benji is this CP84 Guy on HR lol

https://iowa.forums.rivals.com/threads/no-isu-respect-for-ia-receivers.284230/#post-6849993

"That's also why I'm not sold on Purdy yet. I think he's a good QB but we also saw Kempt and Park both play at a high level. Much of that was the ranking of defenses they faced but also having Butler and Montgomery.

I want to see Purdy play at a high level without those two before I agree with how good to great he is."


"This belief that Purdy is substantially more productive than Stanley just has no basis"


"The argument is that Butler greatly inflated Purdy's abilities."