I would completely support this decision. Jay turned traditional sports talk on its head in a good way and he's a fun listen. Way better than almost any other sports talk show.
Have you actually listened to Rome? Or are you just parroting a tired, worn-out, and untrue cliché dating back to an incident from the mid-1990's?
Rome is not a ****. His interviews are extremely respectful and insightful -- and almost always better than the fluff interviews you hear on any other show. Go actually listen to one of his interviews.
He's successful because he understands (rightly so) that nobody wants to hear a bunch of terrible callers. He doesn't allow terrible callers on his show and runs them. There's nothing wrong with that, unless you subscribe to the theory that we should give everyone participation medals and tell everyone they're a beautiful snowflake.
Keith Murphy mentioned on Monday's "Murphy & Andy" show that they made the same decision for WHO-TV's Sound-Off -- fewer callers, more analysis from the hosts. Why? Because the viewers SAID they wanted to hear more takes from the hosts and less callers.