,
Yes, I detest the QB under-the-center triple option offense and a KN hire would disastrous for the following reasons:
1. There is no QB on the current roster or in the existing recruiting pipeline to run it. Lanning has been a Shotgun Spread QB thru HS and at ISU. It would be an absolute waste of his talent for him to play in that offense.
2. The OL for that offense are smaller/quicker OL that cut block for the most part. The returning OL are ill-suited to play in that system. And since cut blocking is illegal in the NFL, good luck trying to recruiting top notch OL who eventually want to play in the NFL. Same deal with WRs (C.Johnson and D.Thomas did not commit to GT while Paul Johnson was HC.) and I would not blame Lazard transferring to a FCS program if KN is hired.
3. Due to #1 and #2, it will take at least 2 or 3 seasons for KN to get the required personnel for that offense. ISU is currently sitting on it's best collection of offensive talent in the past 10 years and it would be a bleepin disaster for the program to squander that talent with KN.
4. KN runs a bleepin phone booth offense. ISU can run the ball effectively out of a Power Shotgun Spread or Shotgun Spread Option which is exactly what they did after the Fat Man left. ISU cannot win with a damn phone booth offense and that includes a pro style under-the-center offense as well but a KN offense is far worse since you can't effectively pass the ball if you're behind.
5. KN has recruited service academy kids for the past 9 years which is far different than recruiting HS and JUCOs in the B12.
KN is the farthest thing from a home run hire for ISU, it would be a damn disaster.