Now picture this, and I realize this is subjective, and I am only trying to come up w/ ideas here...
Have you guys seen this yet? Taken from here:
https://twitter.com/CycloneUniforms/media
Compare this to our current "I-State" logo here
What i think is very interesting is that on the Red helmet above, I like the changes in the color of the logo (w/ the RED helmet). I think the the most important difference is the 'block I', which is gold/yellow, and it only has a 'very subtle' light shade red border. I looks fantastic on the Red helmet. The "I" stands out! Makes it look "classic". I also like how the Red in 'State' w/ a yellow border, also makes the Yellow "I" stand out more.
If we went w/ Gold helmets, you could switch this again. The block "I" would be Red (like it is now), making it stand out on the gold helmet. The yellow border on the "I" would just very lightly contrast w/ the Gold helmet color. It would be identical to the current logo, but ONLY for a Gold lid.
So I guess what I'm saying is, keep the current "I-State" logo, but be willing to flip the color, depending upon whether it is on a Red/Cardinal lid, or a Gold lid. For what it's worth, I like the ability to change the color of the helmets from time to time, to mix up the color scheme a bit.
And, add the secondary, updated 'swirl/twister' logo, to occasionally change things up a bit more.
Lastly, some have said they like the "stenciled" I-State logo; this is not new, as we have done it already. I'm in favor of this, on OCCASION, as well, but it is only my opinion. I think the suggestion above (the I-State logo on the red helmet, w/ the color flip-flop) would look better, and mitigate some of the complaints others have had of the current I-State logo not looking good on the Red helmet, because of the severe two-tone nature of it.
After all, this is one of my secondary choices for uni's, note the stencil logo. Looks great...