Great thread.
Called Directv yesterday to downsize to one tv from three. Saved $40 a month. Still $105 per month... for one tv! Directv is hurting, you can just tell. It's like walking into a kmart in 2006. Directv won't exist in 5 years. I'll keep directv for about 2 more months just in case, i guess i'm sentimental after being a customer for 11 years. If you think about it I've spent a grand total of over $15,000 with them in that time! Crazy.
Started trying out PSVue with Roku Stick two months ago. Is it perfect? No. But the value is undeniable. As others have mentioned, DVR is great just remember to add shows to "My Shows". Get most all my sports. HD. What else do you want? More importantly what else do you need?
Internet access has kept me from switching sooner. I live in rural NE Polk county. Until recently the best available internet service was dial up (which is a crime, imo). Hooked up with Rise Broadband (fixed wireless, think long range WiFi) recently. I bought a 20mps plan, usually get >15mps, which is plenty fine for streaming HD programming. At $55 per month with 24 month contract, i can't complain given i little alternative. My hope is they will continually get better. People say rain/weather causes speed degradation, but i haven't experienced that . What crazy is my Verizon speed here is >100mps, but you think they'd ever make that affordable? Nope. Greedy SOB's. They're getting what they deserve with the heated competition coming form AT&T, TMobile, Sprint and others.
All in all i'm happy. Lots of good info in this thread.