Hilton magic is dead

Ok, I give you alot of credit then for not melting down and seeing the big picture. You were right, we made the tourney easily and took care of business in the 2nd half.

On flip side, nobody can really say for sure on Jan 31st that they knew this would happen. I mean, what if we wouldnt have beaten Kansas? Or we still had Bowie and Holden trying to stop Big 12 frontcourts?

Just because things turned out ok doesnt by any means things were ok on Jan 31st. We were most certainly a bubble team/NIT at that point in time. We had just gotten pretty much blown out in the 2nd half against both Vanderbilt and West Virginia, and our offense looked awful for much of the first half of the season.

And just for the record, Im very pleased with the way things have turned out, I dont think its fair to go back and criticize people for having serious doubts about our post-season hopes on Jan 31st though.

On Jan 31st I knew we would be a tourney team and even bet we wouldn't lose another game in Hilton the rest of the year (and won)
 
  • Winner
Reactions: aauummm
Exactly my point, and which is why I said it wasnt fair to dig up a month old post and rip everyone who was worried at the time.

Again, if this were some run of the mill, "I'm worried about the state of things" thread (of which there were plenty) you'd have a better point. This, however, was not a run of the mill thread. This was the pinnacle of nonsensical hyperbole. THAT is why it was bumped. Because that level of silliness needs to be ridiculed.

As far as "fairness" is concerned. Nobody ever forced anyone to put fingers to keyboard and declare that the sky was falling. Desiigner put his (screen)name on it, as did everyone else. If a poster is so concerned about people pointing out when they were wrong, then don't post in the first place. Otherwise, it pretty much comes with the territory on message boards, so just deal with it.
 
Ok, I give you alot of credit then for not melting down and seeing the big picture. You were right, we made the tourney easily and took care of business in the 2nd half.

On flip side, nobody can really say for sure on Jan 31st that they knew this would happen. I mean, what if we wouldnt have beaten Kansas? Or we still had Bowie and Holden trying to stop Big 12 frontcourts?

Just because things turned out ok doesnt by any means things were ok on Jan 31st. We were most certainly a bubble team/NIT at that point in time. We had just gotten pretty much blown out in the 2nd half against both Vanderbilt and West Virginia, and our offense looked awful for much of the first half of the season.

And just for the record, Im very pleased with the way things have turned out, I dont think its fair to go back and criticize people for having serious doubts about our post-season hopes on Jan 31st though.

Holy cow you sound like Tuco in the other thread a couple of days ago. Let it go.
 
It would be but it's not going to happen. I can understand being a little down on the team but not to the extent of thinking we won't make the tourney. As of right now, I'm predicting a 7 seed.
This where all the level headed posters are bragging about not acting ridiculous? This was from January 19th. Guess I'm pretty awesome too :cool:
 
The guy who you said can't coach made the decision to play Solomon and more than likely had a hand in developing him to the point he was ready to play at this level.
People forget that Solomon played early before he got hurt and, not surprisingly, played like a freshman. He's playing much better now and I have a feeling Prohm had something to do with that.
The rotation of players has also been refined which is a result of good coaching.

Yep, I'm somewhere in the thread saying I was officially judging him due to how bad the WV game went, and how things looked for personal, rotation, etc., and how he wasn't acting on things in the moment very well...he's even talked about it after the KSU game in regards to Young, etc. I think in both seasons he's had some form of 'this is my call' moment at a crucial time and it's paid off.

Also, it's hard to tell how much real buy in there was in December or January, but all indications are that it's occurred the past 2-3 weeks.

Whatever he's doing currently is working, because it was a year ago that ISU was also playing probably their best.
 
Wrong.

After the Jan 31st game we had an NIT resume, we hadnt beaten Kansas yet, our best win at the time was Tech. It easy to go back now and say this but revisionist history isnt the best way to look at things.
Almost every bracketology site had us in the tournament at that point. It was never as bad as some made it seem
 
  • Agree
Reactions: CyTwins
People who lose their **** over how a sports team performs really deserve to have it brought back up later when the sky doesn't fall.

In theory they should learn from it.
 
People remember stupid negative things and point them out. Nobody points out stupid positive things, because then you just look like an ass hole.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: everyyard
This thread should win an award for sporting the stupidest ******* title ever. And when I say ever, boy do I mean EVER!!!!! Holy ****
 
Glad he corrected things. Things were NOT GOOD mid season and I will absolutely stand by that. Anybody that lived through the dark ages (McDermott) should realize we don't take the magic for granted.
Things were not good, but even in the good seasons there were mid-season slumps. It never failed, the sky was falling, the team was lazy, heroball, students and old people are killing Hilton, on and on. Yet things were never as bad as CF seemed to think.
 
I just hope everyone remembers this thread next season if/when the Cyclones start out slowly as they try to find their post-Core Four identity.

But, I bet we won't.
Can we just get the "see Prohm can only win with Fred's players" threads out of the way now? Better yet, the Prohm is dumb because he "chose" Carter over Ernst threads every time Ernst goes for 6 and 4 for Xavier.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron