FB Recruiting Avg Rating Comparison
- Thread starter ShopTalk
- Start date
I'm not excited because this class is some juggernaut or something. I'm excited that it's even an average class (for ISU) considering the circumstances. CPR wasn't going to bring in anything better and he was here for over a half a decade.
You're not understanding what Shop is saying. It doesn't matter who the coach is. We'll always be losers. Even Saban can't be successful here. The best thing for us to do is shut down the program.
Dude grow up. You d realize that these player ratings, while a part, is not an exact science and 100% subjective. For example you may have (2) kids who analysts have as 3 star recruits and both are attending a rivals regional camp only (1) of them showed up for whatever reason to be evaluated and possibly negatively affecting the other ones rating...this is one example of the subjectivity of the dozens. I'm not saying it's totally inaccurate but you can't pull one factor and make a sweeping analysis. It would be like if this Isu class ends up being ranked in the top 35 at end of class(which could happen btw) but a part of that ranking is the fact we will be signing maybe 25 kids boosting the ranking over oh say A school like Texas...when we look deeper Texas may have only signed 12 kids.
Who knows more about the potential and quality of these kids most? Coaches..it's prob a better judge of the class to look at who else was recruiting them and who else offered them.
You completely leave out what the new leadership will mean. This is a coaching TEAM that has worked together for years and it sure sounds like they are all on the same page and actually have a PLAN that has worked. The previous coaching staff has had so much friction up to and including the fattest OC dropping deuces in towels and expecting staff to clean up after him.
Someone mentioned Iowa and they are an excellent case in consistent schemes, consistent coaching and steady leadership.
Plus this years class is only a little over half filled. But I'll throw you a bone and say it will all probably suck again if that makes you feel better.
Is it really peeing in someone's Cheerios or pointing out that while the last staff wasn't all world they weren't Satan incarnate either as many have seemed to point out in every other thread? Can't we be happy about the current staff without vilifying the previous one?
Also...like I said it's not an exact science and is too subjective like others have said to just take into account avg player ratings. Way too many misses in how these guys sitting in chairs watching highlight films evaluate..
These players were below the .800 rating or right at it..
Jake Knott
Jeremy Reeves
Josh Lenz
Jeff Woody
David Johnson(UNI) thought I'd throw him in there
Deon Broomfield
Jansen Watson
Farniok
David Irving
Oni Omoelle
Stephen Rump(was a .745 btw, pretty bad)
KO..Kelechi
Collin Franklin...was a .722
ARob
Reggie Stephens
Lamarcus Hicks
Tim Dobbins
Btw...almost all of these players spent time in the NFL and some are still there. What's funny is several of Danny Mac classes were ranked in the 40's overall yet the avg. player rating was below the .800 mark.
These players were below the .800 rating or right at it..
Jake Knott
Jeremy Reeves
Josh Lenz
Jeff Woody
David Johnson(UNI) thought I'd throw him in there
Deon Broomfield
Jansen Watson
Farniok
David Irving
Oni Omoelle
Stephen Rump(was a .745 btw, pretty bad)
KO..Kelechi
Collin Franklin...was a .722
ARob
Reggie Stephens
Lamarcus Hicks
Tim Dobbins
Btw...almost all of these players spent time in the NFL and some are still there. What's funny is several of Danny Mac classes were ranked in the 40's overall yet the avg. player rating was below the .800 mark.
Why is average rating better than this? This is a much more logical way of actually rating a class because not every player has the same impact. Your formula gives as much weight to the 25th best recruit in a class to the best recruit in a class despite the fact that the 25th best recruit has little chance of playing regardless of the team he signs for.
Last edited:
That's not how this works at PolarExtremeFanatic, Velo! ****!!!!!! Burn it ******* down!!!!!!!!!!!1!!!1!!!!!!!
That can't be correct. How could these low life 2 and 3 star players beat two Big 5 schools and get ranked. WHAT IS THIS WORLD COMING TOO????? HOW COULD THAT HAPPEN?????
ANSWER: "THE PROCESS"
