Honest question: do these so called 'experts' actually review tape, evaluate competition, interview coaches. Or, as I suspect, do they ride the coat tails of coaches offers. "Hey! Matt Campbell just offered this guy. Let's bump him up." Just curious.
Rivals won't rate a guy above a 2-star unless/until they either see him in person (best way) or watch video highlights. And I think multiple Rivals guys have to do one or the other before they assess a ranking. They CLAIM that they don't let who offers influence their decisions, but obviously, if a kid has 30 high profile offers and they've rated him a 3-star, they will take a second look at him to see if a boost is warranted.