I hear what you're saying, as it always surprises me too, but it shouldn't as I've observed the craziness here for far too many years. The common theme I notice on CF is that the loudest / most frequent posters get really up, excited and overconfident when the team wins a few games, and then the loudest / most frequent posters after the team loses a few games get really down on the team and demoralized. Hah. The answer lies in the middle. The team is not as good, or as bad as so many think.
To regress to the mean, the team should probably lose this game. Anything is possible though, and it strikes me as a pretty evenly matched game. Just enjoy the ride. Hopefully they can pull this off setting up a potentially magical November with so much to play for.