.

When 90% of the posts aren't mentioning what % the employer pays we have no idea if any of these plans are actually well priced or not. A few posts ago the guy mentioned he only pays 20% but the cost is still outrageous. Other posters "I pay $400" and we have absolutely no clue what their plan actually costs.

It gets into the big picture of why this is a difficult political issue. People don't even understand the full cost of their coverage at the most basic level. I don't blame people, life is hard and we're busy. It's an overly complex structure to pay for something. Without knowing the % people are paying for their plans we really aren't getting what is probably the key piece of information to know if they should look for a new job.

One of the earliest posts said they were paying $1300 for a family. I can't give them advice...no one should give them advice...without knowing what % of the cost of the plan that is. Honestly we should know what their salary is. Some employers pay a low % but pay high salaries, it could be worth it. I get people wouldn't post their salaries but we can't understand their company without knowing what % of the plan they pay.

If a company has a horrible plan while covering 80% they can switch plans and you save. It's at least a possibility. If a company is only paying 40-50% you're kind of F'd no matter what change they are going to make.

You aren't going to know what the employer pays. The only place you might find what they claim to pay is from the IRS tax form if they have to give you one.
 
I pay $18 a month for just me with $600 a year for an HSA. I suggest selling your soul and working for a big company.
I was just about to say....Go get a job for WF and swallow that bullet for the health insurance alone.
 
You aren't going to know what the employer pays. The only place you might find what they claim to pay is from the IRS tax form if they have to give you one.

It's on my paystub, but that may not be common.

Every employer should make that amount clear to employees -- annually it's a 5-figure benefit for many (most?) employers, yet most do a poor job of making sure their employees know that.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: khardbored
My company covers 100% of individual insurance on our choice of 5 insurance plans, but employees have to pick up 100% of the difference if they want the +1, or family options.
 
It's on my paystub, but that may not be common.

Every employer should make that amount clear to employees -- annually it's a 5-figure benefit for many (most?) employers, yet most do a poor job of making sure their employees know that.

We show our employees annually the cost of insurance at renewal time.
 
I have found that High Deductible Health Plans (HDHP's) are best if you use very little medical care or a whole lot of health care...

So I always "do the math" at each open enrollment assuming the worst case scenario, taking premiums, expenses, deductible, etc into consideration...
This is exactly my situation - every time I run the numbers each year, it pencils out (based on premiums, deductible and OOP max, co-pay %, employer HSA contribution, etc) that my HDHP makes most sense. The likelihood of using the "sweet spot" amount of benefits to justify a traditional plan is so low that I'd rather roll the dice. It helps to know that the HSA contributions I'm making in place of monthly plan premiums will cover my max-case OOP limit scenario for any given year, and that the $ rolls over if I don't use it.

Hard to beat the triple tax advantage of an HSA account, but the HDHP plan premiums need to be low enough to justify the higher deductible limits and make the numbers work by redirecting those funds into my own account.
 
It's on my paystub, but that may not be common.

Every employer should make that amount clear to employees -- annually it's a 5-figure benefit for many (most?) employers, yet most do a poor job of making sure their employees know that.

My brother's a high level financial analyst for a large health insurance company and he said most of the data provided that people are basing their percentages on in this thread(paychecks, benefits statements, etc.)are a bunch of crap and not reflective of what the company is actually paying, so unless you're a higher up directly involved in overseeing your company's health insurance plan, you can take the numbers you're seeing with a grain of salt. Kind of like MSRP prices on things you buy.
 
  • Winner
Reactions: ArgentCy
I no longer have to pay for health insurance (monthly premiums), but my company's insurance is total trash. I honestly feel bad for people that are making $12 an hour and having to spend minimum $450/month for a family. Deductibles are insanely high as well.
 
$18,000 is what my company pays for my family’s Medical, Dental, Vision, Life/AD&D, and Disability

$2,360 is what I pay.

So I pay 13% of what my employer pays. I feel very blessed and know that may change at any point. When I first started with this company we didn't pay any of the premium, now we just pay for my wife and kid's health coverage.
 
HDP family with $3600 deductible and OOPM of $7200. monthly premium $90, with HSA company contribution of $1800 yearly.
 
In general, I very much agree with you that bigger companies have better plans. I will say, in my case, I was surprised to find that my current company (pretty small, 150 employees) had better benefits than my old job (huge company, 5000 employees).

My old company had a $300 premium with only HSA options. Deductible was $3600 and they gave you $1200 a year into HSA. Out of pocket max was $8000. My new company is the same premium, but no HSA, with $800 deductible and $1600 out of pocket max.

I know by and large, big companies have better plans just because they have a bigger pool and more negotiating power. However, I’d recommend anyone get the info from a company first before automatically assuming a small company will have worse benefits.



My point is that I'm no longer focused on "what are my premiums now." Instead, I want to know what my premiums will be after a major, major medical expense. If we were still on my old individual family plan with Wellmark, I think they would have to drop me. But now that we are on a school district's group plan, our premiums won't change any more than anyone else's.

P.S. Oh gawd, I've become a socialist!
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure what we pay, since we're on my wife's insurance. She's a university professor and there's a medical school and university hospital associated with it. If we agree to use the university's resources, things are pretty cheap.

Like, "had a c-section baby last year and paid under $100" cheap.

If you step out of network, though, watch out!

Meanwhile, I switched jobs, and the company that I work for (engineering design firm) has absolute garbage for their insurance options.
 
Ours is garbage. The "affordable" plan we have for my wife and daughter is about $800/month with an $8800 deductible. They each made a trip to the doctor last year. Insurance paid $10 for each visit, leaving us with $150 and $160.

We couldn't afford mine, so I just manage a couple of potentially catastrophic conditions on my own. Avoided a very possible heart attack yesterday, so I'll just pretend the situation is good.
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: cowgirl836
Ours is garbage. The "affordable" plan we have for my wife and daughter is about $800/month with an $8800 deductible. They each made a trip to the doctor last year. Insurance paid $10 for each visit, leaving us with $150 and $160.

We couldn't afford mine, so I just manage a couple of potentially catastrophic conditions on my own. Avoided a very possible heart attack yesterday, so I'll just pretend the situation is good.


That's kind of where I'm at. Tiny employer (3 employees) that doesn't offer coverage and I don't make bad money by any means. Even with subsidies coverage is $550 per month for just me for a $12k out of pocket max. I'm bankrupt either way so I am not throwing money away at premiums.

I'm a single dad, daughter is on HAWK-I, which is an awesome program.
 
  • Friendly
Reactions: cyrevkah

Help Support Us

Become a patron