Who was more "IN"?

[atlantacyclone]

I still don’t understand how you don’t call that a TD.... the ball was kind of up in his hands ... but it clearly didn’t move until he was way past the goal line... if it was a pass I could see them calling it incomplete...

 

[cypher]

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

yes, that was a bad call imho, so the bad touchdown

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

 

[cypher]

yes, that was a bad call imho, so the bad touchdown

the bad touchdown call makes up for it? the better team won!

 

[DurangoCy]

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

shhhh

 

[jaj040]

The ball comes out when DM's forearm hits Campos is the back of the leg. Campos is fully standing in the end zone when he is hit.

 

[LarryISU]

shhhh

I went to the Men's Room right after the play, but if "roughing" was a questionable call, then the defensive holding on the same play still gives us a first down and we get the same result. So, it's a moot point.

 

[Die4Cy]

 

[Gunnerclone]

I haven't been following threads most of the day, did we all agree to just ignore the roughing the passer call that gave us a touchdown?

I don’t even know what you’re talking about.

 

[LindenCy]

Wow, he was a lot more in than I remembered.

 

[BoxsterCy]

Was sitting in the Quad Cities with BIL and three nephew-in-laws. No ISU fans, just Iowa grad, Wartburg, Michigan State etc. All four of them were saying, that's a TD there's no way they don't overturn the fumble call. Me "We're ******".

After the replay, them: Me:

Same neutral guys were all WTF after the replay on the PI on the Tigers last series.

 

[IASTATE07]

Same neutral guys were all WTF after the replay on the PI on the Tigers last series.

That was bad seeing it from the stands thinking WTF. Then watching the replay on the jumbotron really had me dropping F bombs.

 

[Jonyrose]

Can we petition the NCAA for an asterisk?

Admitting the call was wrong doesn’t affect the outcome of the game and we get to rightfully claim what our guys truly earned, the only team to not lose a fumble through an entire season.

 

[Cyclonepride]

Told my wife he was in by a foot after the first replay. This one isn’t that hard.

 

[awd4cy]

Ok, just checking that we're ignoring that.

Might as well, didn’t think that was that bad of a roughing the passer call. Also there were 2 fouls on that play I thought anyways.

 

[Cyclone.TV]

He was in. But maybe a block in the back.

 

[chuckd4735]

Watching the replays, I was only about 99% sure he didnt fumble before crossing the goal line, and by the letter of the law, was not indisputable. My bigger beef was how it wasn't called a TD on the field. I thought I had seen the ref on the line call it a TD but one of the other refs came in and said fumble.

College replay needs to go more to what the NFL has so camera angles can be synched up, and replay if done in a Central location (ie the league offices). When you snyc up the angles, there is 100% no question DM was in.

 

[FinalFourCy]

10-3 was a hell of a job by the staff.

 

[CTTB78]

We'll need a modification to the "He was in" T-shirts.....

 

[cyfanatic13]

I went to the Men's Room right after the play, but if "roughing" was a questionable call, then the defensive holding on the same play still gives us a first down and we get the same result. So, it's a moot point.

The second penalty on that play was on Memphis on the interception return, so they would have gotten the ball had there been no roughing the passer penalty

 

[mj4cy]

Crazy what a game of inches football is. We were literally 3 plays from 11-2.