Who was more "IN"?

[Rogue52]

In regards to the roughing the passer call, there was also a defensive holding call on the play. We were going in to score regardless.

In regards to the fumble call, just another travesty of replay.

 

[Beyerball]

Anyone have a still photo of Montgomery crossing the goal line? And Also a still if Butler reach for pylon? I’m shocked that Butler play wasnt reviewed..absolutely horrendous to not even review that. Every single scoring play or close scoring play has to be looked at..not necassarily stopping play but replay booth is supposed to look at every scoring play or potential scoring play.

Butler foot honestly looked in..it was real close but ABC didnt replay it and zoom in. Still upset about DM fumble call..what a horrible job by replay officials..I mean that wasnt even close really. I would truly like to know what their reasoning was.

 

[3TrueFans]

In regards to the roughing the passer call, there was also a defensive holding call on the play. We were going in to score regardless.

In regards to the fumble call, just another travesty of replay.

The other penalty was a block in the back on the return after the interception so it would have stood as Memphis ball.

 

[CycloneErik]

Wow, he was a lot more in than I remembered.

Yeah, this vote is a draw for me now. They're both plainly in.

 

[buf87]

I wonder how much the ball being in an awkward position at the start of Montgomery's carry had to do with whether he had control?

 

[mikeiastat]

In regards to the roughing the passer call, there was also a defensive holding call on the play. We were going in to score regardless.

I'm pretty sure that this is incorrect. The holding was not "defensive holding" in the passing game infraction. I'm pretty sure it was post possession holding on the interception return. If that is the case, Memphis would have retained possession and we would not have gotten the touchdown.

 

[Jonyrose]

Anyone have a still photo of Montgomery crossing the goal line? And Also a still if Butler reach for pylon? I’m shocked that Butler play wasnt reviewed..absolutely horrendous to not even review that. Every single scoring play or close scoring play has to be looked at..not necassarily stopping play but replay booth is supposed to look at every scoring play or potential scoring play.

Butler foot honestly looked in..it was real close but ABC didnt replay it and zoom in. Still upset about DM fumble call..what a horrible job by replay officials..I mean that wasnt even close really. I would truly like to know what their reasoning was.

I thought he same on the butler almost td, but if you watch the replay from the sideline side, his toes drag out of bounds before he hits the pylon.

 

[barometriclow]

See pic

https://sports.yahoo.com/iowa-state...call-beat-memphis-liberty-bowl-211039528.html

 

[IASTATE07]

Anyone have a still photo of Montgomery crossing the goal line? And Also a still if Butler reach for pylon? I’m shocked that Butler play wasnt reviewed..absolutely horrendous to not even review that. Every single scoring play or close scoring play has to be looked at..not necassarily stopping play but replay booth is supposed to look at every scoring play or potential scoring play.

Butler foot honestly looked in..it was real close but ABC didnt replay it and zoom in. Still upset about DM fumble call..what a horrible job by replay officials..I mean that wasnt even close really. I would truly like to know what their reasoning was.

Pretty sure if he was ruled out on the field that it isn't reviewable on the Butler play. Similar to Kempt being called for stepping out of bounds against TT.

 

[CtownCyclone]

Anyone have a still photo of Montgomery crossing the goal line? And Also a still if Butler reach for pylon? I’m shocked that Butler play wasnt reviewed..absolutely horrendous to not even review that. Every single scoring play or close scoring play has to be looked at..not necassarily stopping play but replay booth is supposed to look at every scoring play or potential scoring play.

Butler foot honestly looked in..it was real close but ABC didnt replay it and zoom in. Still upset about DM fumble call..what a horrible job by replay officials..I mean that wasnt even close really. I would truly like to know what their reasoning was.

We were sitting in that corner, and he looked out for sure to me watching it live.

Montgomery was so in, it wasn't even funny. Seneca too (also was at that game, play also happened right in front of me).

 

[Cyclad]

The other penalty was a block in the back on the return after the interception so it would have stood as Memphis ball.

No, it was holding, per the referee

 

[3TrueFans]

No, it was holding, per the referee

I'm glad you're so sure, but it wasn't.