Hickory hall was great for us. Reception only cost approx $2500 - 3000 including the DJ. Hickory Hall waives the building rent if you go over so much in food and drink so I had no problem ordering extra food (for me to eat later) in order to get for rent waived.
That's the same thing we're doing. We're ordering extra food/beer just to make sure we go over the "minimum" amount. It's actually not that bad of a deal.