We know iSu would have been better with how those players turned out. There doesn’t happen to be any evidence that they would have become those players with the coaching and development they would have received at isu.
Why is Kinnick Stadium considered historic?
- Thread starter ScottyP
- Start date
We know iSu would have been better with how those players turned out. There doesn’t happen to be any evidence that they would have become those players with the coaching and development they would have received at isu.
He’s on a roll let him go. I expect he will come back with some kind of reference to Brock.
ISU would be better with those players just like Iowa would be better with those players they missed out which you think is no big deal
So he is saying there is no difference in getting Higdon (3 star) instead of Eric Graham (3 star)?
Still no evidence that iSu would have developed the players mentioned to what they became at Iowa.
If you don't think ISU would have been better with those players on the roster you're dumber than I thought
I am saying Iowa will take a 2-3 star player and get them to the same level of production as what Higdon will end up with. So in the end getting one 3 star vs another really doesn’t matter.
You think Iowa will have a player that's as productive as Higdon this year?
FWIW Higdon was replaced in his class by a guy that doesn't play for Iowa anymore so not sure how you can spin it into no big deal
I am sure iSu would have been better with how the Iowa players turned out. What I am also saying is that as it stands now there is no evidence that iSu has the coaching or development staff to have gotten the players to the same level as Iowa did. Is this that hard to understand?
Here is what you asked me. Yes ISU would have been better with those players on their roster. I have no clue if Desmond King would have ended up a 5th round draft pick if he went to ISU if that's what you're trying to get at
I told you why it wasn’t a big deal. Iowa will end up with players that meet or exceed the production of Higdon.
Did Higdon have the production that Wadley had last year? No and it didn’t matter one bit that Wadley was a 2 star and considered a lessor player going into college.
Here is what I know as it stands today, the current iSu staff hasn’t proven they can match the coaching and development that Iowa has consistently delivered. You can dance around that all you want but it still won’t change anything.
That's not what you asked. You asked me if ISU would be better with those players on their roster and I answered yes
I am confident Young or IKM will match Higdon’s production from his sophomore year where he played in 12 games had 72 carries for 425 yards and 6 TD’s. Anything more than that and Iowa’s players would be on a pace to exceed Higdon’s production for his career.
So what evidence to you have that iSu would have coached and developed those players to the same level Iowa did?
I never said they would, you asked me if ISU would be better with them on their roster and I said yes. That's it