Teams
Forum List
Toggle sidebar

*** Stranger Things Mafia Game Thread ***

cyguytillidie said:
Cubs has been very vocal in reminding everyone about his charge against gipper Day 2 but are we just letting him off for his charade last night?
Click to expand...

cyguytillidie said:
And not to sound like a broken record but why is Vikes perceived innocent now?
Day 2 - spiker and gipper both vote for azuth giving him his 2nd & 3rd vote to tie him with Vikes.
Day 3 - Votes gipper when the ball was already rolling downhill. I suppose he and gipper could have stayed on Clonies. Maybe they thought writing was on the wall and he might as well jump on before it looks to suspicious? Then Vecna puts kill in.
Day 4 - Vikes finally not voting for self preservation. Basically throws vote away on Clonies while spiker is on the chopping block.
Click to expand...
I’m definitely leaning inno on both but not 100% sure. I think there’s better options for a couple days and then if they’re still around next week we go after them
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Cyclonscin
Cyclonscin said:
Personally, I think his day 3 vote nearly fully exonerates him. Switching off of Clonies to Gipper when he did was arguably the deciding vote, even if it was out of self preservation. Besides, if he would have stuck with Clonies all it would take is a Gipper flip from Vikes to Clonies to spare Vikes and Gipper.

That said, I never trust a Vikings fan. Or a Cubs fan, for that matter.
Click to expand...
I definitely looked over gipper’s vote for Vikes the first time through.
At the time Vikes switched to gipper count was:
Gipper: 5
Vikes: 4
Clonies: 4
His vote also shifted Clonies to make it 7-3-3. If he stood pat, gipper could have made it a 5-5 tie with he and Clonies. Suppose that would have made most sense but there were still votes to be made. Could have been nervous that he ends up in randomizer before using the Vecna kill?
Gipper’s vote for Vikes made it:
Gipper: 7
Vikes: 4
Clonies: 3
Again, maybe makes more sense to bump Clonies up there but writing was on the wall. Vote against Vikes helps with his innocence going forward.

Lot of ifs and maybes here but that’s what makes this a game, right?
 
cyfanatic13 said:
I’m definitely leaning inno on both but not 100% sure. I think there’s better options for a couple days and then if they’re still around next week we go after them
Click to expand...
Fair enough.
Digging through Vikes history came with a lot of assumptions. Your SaraV angle is a bit more straight forward.
Day 1 - mafia on mafia
Day 2/3 - throw aways
Day 4 - Late rescind off spiker during Cubs chaos. Votes next leading but getter, SCN.

vote SaraV
 
cyguytillidie said:
I definitely looked over gipper’s vote for Vikes the first time through.
At the time Vikes switched to gipper count was:
Gipper: 5
Vikes: 4
Clonies: 4
His vote also shifted Clonies to make it 7-3-3. If he stood pat, gipper could have made it a 5-5 tie with he and Clonies. Suppose that would have made most sense but there were still votes to be made. Could have been nervous that he ends up in randomizer before using the Vecna kill?
Gipper’s vote for Vikes made it:
Gipper: 7
Vikes: 4
Clonies: 3
Again, maybe makes more sense to bump Clonies up there but writing was on the wall. Vote against Vikes helps with his innocence going forward.

Lot of ifs and maybes here but that’s what makes this a game, right?
Click to expand...
I keep forgetting about the Vecna kill. If Vecna was worried about going home the next day, then Vikes is the only one that really makes sense. But Vecna could've also just been trying to cause chaos.
 
cyfanatic13 said:
I keep forgetting about the Vecna kill. If Vecna was worried about going home the next day, then Vikes is the only one that really makes sense. But Vecna could've also just been trying to cause chaos.
Click to expand...
Vecna could just as easily have been someone laying low and receiving very few votes like Sara, GBlade, or Cows.

And Moores' theory about targeting him specifically so that we'd go after Clonies appears to at least hold some water, so that could explain the hit.

I say start with the quieter suspicious folks and go from there.

Vote GBlade
 
Day 5 Vote Count

1 - ISUCubswin - JM4CY (9:42 a.m.)
1 - SaraV - cyguytillidie (10:32 a.m.)
1 - GBlade - Cyclonscin (10:40 a.m.)
 
Cyclonscin said:
I'm definitely at a disadvantage without knowing the typical habits/personalities of the other players. So that stuff is good to know.

Updating my list after Cubs pointed out that Discy is almost certainly Steve. Leaving a little bit of wiggle room in case someone has been remarkably sly and sneaky about using the magic words. I'd say anyone below SCNCY is still a potential suspect to some degree.

MOST INNO
Salty
JM
Vikes
Discy
SCNCY
Cubs
CyFan13
CyGuy
CyFan21
Cows
Sara
GBlade
MOST SUS
Click to expand...
This list is almost exactly what I have, switching your name with mine.

The three people I’m most curious of are GBlade, Cows, and SaraV.
 
Not sure if spreading out votes is the right call but maybe we'll get some more discussion from the quiet ones. Vote meowcows
 
Cyclonscin said:
I'm definitely at a disadvantage without knowing the typical habits/personalities of the other players. So that stuff is good to know.

Updating my list after Cubs pointed out that Discy is almost certainly Steve. Leaving a little bit of wiggle room in case someone has been remarkably sly and sneaky about using the magic words. I'd say anyone below SCNCY is still a potential suspect to some degree.

MOST INNO
Salty
JM
Vikes
Discy
SCNCY
Cubs
CyFan13
CyGuy
CyFan21
Cows
Sara
GBlade
MOST SUS
Click to expand...
I also was the deciding vote on spiked but whatever vote sara
 
cyfanatic13 said:
Not sure if spreading out votes is the right call but maybe we'll get some more discussion from the quiet ones. Vote meowcows
Click to expand...
rescind cubs vote cows

Too quiet, too sneaky. Not as much that theres things that have occurred to make me feel hes mafia as much doing anything to make me think he's not.
 
Day 5 Vote Count

2 - SaraV - cyguytillidie (10:32 a.m.), discydisc (11:08 a.m.)
2 - MeowingCows - cyfanatic13 (10:45 a.m.), JM4CY (11:10 a.m.)
1 - GBlade - Cyclonscin (10:40 a.m.)
0 - ISUCubswin - JM4CY (9:42 a.m., rescind 11:10 a.m.)
 
Last edited:
I don't play D&D never have. I preferred Pokemon cards growing up.

VOTE Cyclonscin

For hiding as Steve. None of the other mafia did, but I assume one of them would. Also has voted for mafia everyday except day 1? Looks a bit too good.
 
GBlade said:
I don't play D&D never have. I preferred Pokemon cards growing up.

VOTE Cyclonscin

For hiding as Steve. None of the other mafia did, but I assume one of them would. Also has voted for mafia everyday except day 1? Looks a bit too good.
Click to expand...
Whoops read it wrong you voted for Vikes not gripper on Day 3. Point still stands though.
 
giphy.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Help Support Us

Become a patron
Top Bottom