As someone who has had to recruit for the Knights that change in tone and body language could be one of several things:I like that term! I use the heathen term mostly in jest with my wife because we typically volunteer with our Catholic church and help out with events and stuff, but it's funny how you can usually see a pretty obvious change in attitude towards me when they learn I'm not actually Catholic. I can't tell you how many times I've been recruited to join the Knights of Columbus, and their tone and body language changes pretty dramatically when I say I'm not actually Catholic.
- Thank God I don't have to bother this guy anymore since he isn't Catholic
- Crap, I'm not going to recruit this guy so they will get off my back about not recruiting anyone.
- Good, now I can go over and get a piece of that blueberry pie before it is gone.
- Do I start talking to him about converting? No, that sounds like way too much work.
Finally, if they treat you like less because you aren't Catholic, they aren't very good Catholics. I have been surprised to learn how many converts there are in my KC council - and how active they are. It took me over 20 years of going to the Catholic Church regularly before I was ready to convert. If you alienate people you are doing more harm than good.
