Question for Iowa fans

[CyTwins]

Just to reiterate from @TRYHARDER

2nd team All Big 12 QB - worse than Stanley

Honorable mention All Big 12 QB - better than Stanley

 

[TRYHARDER]

Purdy was better than Brewer? I'm confused. Passer Rating? QBR? PFF? Wins and losses? what metric are you using?

Bump for CyTwins. Why are you suddenly avoiding PFF?

 

[CyTwins]

Bump for CyTwins. Why are you suddenly avoiding PFF?

PFF has Purdy the 8th best QB in the country and Brewer 15th. They have Brewer 2nd team All Conference and Purdy 3rd team. I already said this so what am I avoiding?

 

[TRYHARDER]

PFF has Purdy the 8th best QB in the country and Brewer 15th. They have Brewer 2nd team All Conference and Purdy 3rd team. I already said this so what am I avoiding?

Why would they have Brewer 2nd team all conference and not Purdy?

 

[CyTwins]

Why would they have Brewer 2nd team all conference and not Purdy?

You'd have to ask them. Big 12 coaches had Purdy second team and Brewer HM

 

[TRYHARDER]

You'd have to ask them. Big 12 coaches had Purdy second team and Brewer HM

strange huh?

 

[CyTwins]

strange huh?

What's strange is you think an HM All Conference QB is better than Stanley but the 2nd team All Conference QB isn't

 

[Cyclone.TV]

PFF has Purdy the 8th best QB in the country and Brewer 15th. They have Brewer 2nd team All Conference and Purdy 3rd team. I already said this so what am I avoiding?

It's almost as if PFF is worthless.

 

[CyTwins]

It's almost as if Stanley is worthless.

Agreed

 

[Cyclone.TV]

PFF is worthless

Couldn't agree more.

 

[CyTwins]

Couldn't agree more.

Who's better, Purdy or Stanley?

 

[TRYHARDER]

Who's better, Purdy or Stanley?

Someone who is objective would pick Purdy. I never said I was objective. But neither are you.

 

[CyTwins]

Someone who is objective would pick Purdy. I never said I was objective. But neither are you.

I'd take Wirfs over JGJ and those two are way closer than Purdy and Stanley are so no that's not correct

 

[TRYHARDER]

I'd take Wirfs over JGJ and those two are way closer than Purdy and Stanley are so no that's not correct

You don't include Welch at LB so I think you lose credibility there.

 

[TRYHARDER]

I'd take Wirfs over JGJ and those two are way closer than Purdy and Stanley are so no that's not correct

LOL. Wirfs is the BIG 10 olineman of the year. Really going out on a limb there!

 

[CyTwins]

You don't include Welch at LB so I think you lose credibility there.

Spears, Vance and Rose were all HM All Conference which means some coaches voted them first or second team All Conference. It's not like they're scrubs

 

[CyTwins]

LOL. Wirfs is the BIG 10 olineman of the year. Really going out on a limb there!

And JGJ was first team All Conference and HM OL of the year. Wirfs and JGJ are closer in terms of abilities than Purdy and Stanley

 

[TRYHARDER]

Spears, Vance and Rose were all HM All Conference which means some coaches voted them first or second team All Conference. It's not like they're scrubs

Didn't say they were but once Welch was healthy he was a tackling machine.

 

[CyTwins]

Didn't say they were but once Welch was healthy he was a tackling machine.

Vance missed time due to injuries and still had 6.5 sacks this season. Look you think Nate Stanley is a better college quarterback than Brock Purdy. Obviously you're not good at judging talent

 

[TRYHARDER]

Vance missed time due to injuries and still had 6.5 sacks this season. Look you think Nate Stanley is a better college quarterback than Brock Purdy. Obviously you're not good at judging talent

I can live with that.