Plenty of good weekend left so I'll try to keep this as concise as I can -
Offense
Defense
As @JStanz51 pointed out, in the first half I did not like all the trickery from Tom Manning. The game was close and I thought it was getting too cute out there. The call to have Breece do a half back pass downfield was confusing. I did like seeing Dekkers get experience in the drive down the field and his TD. Yes his pick was bad but that drive showed me some accuracy and confidence from him and he had command out of the offense.
Personally I think Manning is in a tough spot because he's playing with a good QB, great RB, but clearly one of the worst OL's in the league. And that is tough on any play caller. Go win the next 2 so we can finish 8-5. I will never be totally down on a 1 score loss to OU, because I can recount the games with them as a little kid where it was 35-7 at half routinely.
Offense
- OL - I do get Oklahoma blitzed, I also recognize they have 2 NFL guys on their D line in Nico Bonnito and Perrion Winfrey. Buy sweet moses 7 sacks is unacceptable. OU was in the backfield immediately, our OL showed no confidence out there, showed no grit at the line, and just looked off all day. Jeff Meyers should be on the hot seat and I wouldn't bat an eye if he was let go. (given how much the o line has regressed in 2021). This unit is hurting the team lately, and today they couldn't open up ANY room for Breece.
- TCU game, bowl game, and spring ball are big for development. I need to see Hufford be more consistent he had a couple bad penalties out there. I am continuously down on Trevor Downing, not sure what is happening with him, and Newell straight up got abused today. We clearly need a better starting 5 on this unit. I will be curious what Hayden Pauls and Tyler Miller can do in the spring, I also think we should be looking to upgrade at guard. Transfer portal season is soon.
- Charlie Kolar's best game as a cyclone. Should be a 3rd to 5th round pick. Today showed exactly why. He's so smooth as a pass catcher, runs awesome routes, and catches everything. NFL talent personnel had to have been impressed by today. I as a fan will really miss watching him play.
- Joe Scates - two catches for 38 yards welcome back young man. But what is the deal with him? He has clearly been suspended for a month. I'm happy he's a cyclone do not get me wrong. But at a certain point he's a junior in this program, either "get it" and stay with this program and buy in, or just leave.
- Jaylin Noel - another positive. He had 7 for 32 yards so the avg per catch leaves some to be desired after the catch, but I really, really like this young man's future.
- Purdy was solid most of the game despite getting wrecking balled about 20x out there. I have huge respect for him playing most of the game given his line today. The last pass was a tough one, he floated it high to avoid it getting tipped, and it was just a foot and a half too high.
- If Breece wants to shut it down in the bowl then so be it. He's given his all to this program. Let's see what Jihrehl Brock and Deon Silas can do with the rock.
- Andrew Mevis is Iowa State special teams right now, wish we had another year of him
Defense
- Mike Rose, one of his best games. 2 sacks, 3 tfl's. As an nfl talent evaluator, he should go in the top 5 rounds. What a stud. And he's doing all of this while not close to 100%.
- Craig McDonald - 10 tackles and 1 int. This dude to me is going to be a leader on the D next year. He plays so physical, and is generally in the right spot. A stronger, perhaps quicker version of Eisworth to me.
- #15 Myles Purchase. When Kymani King got hurt he played a lot, and he looked very good in meaningful minutes. He was in on a couple deflections and didn't get burned today. Really like his future here. I also hope his stud linebacker brother joins the program.
- The LB core (minus caleb williams long td run) I thought was very good all day. Gerry Vaughn is not huge but I do like the way he plays, fairly reliable.
- Will McDonald is clearly dinged up but ended up with a good day out there.
- Blake Peterson is gritty and has size, I like his future in the defense. Isiah Lee was effective some.
- This defense needs a corner to step up to play with Myles Purchase out there for 2022, but I do feel confident about Purchase now moving forward. He was covering 4* guys in the second half and didn't get beat once
- Our pass D to me is much better right now. Watching Tech tonight (of course their QB can't hit water if he fell out of a boat tonight), that was kind of a weird outing last week which i chalk up to a qb having an oddly accurate day.
As @JStanz51 pointed out, in the first half I did not like all the trickery from Tom Manning. The game was close and I thought it was getting too cute out there. The call to have Breece do a half back pass downfield was confusing. I did like seeing Dekkers get experience in the drive down the field and his TD. Yes his pick was bad but that drive showed me some accuracy and confidence from him and he had command out of the offense.
Personally I think Manning is in a tough spot because he's playing with a good QB, great RB, but clearly one of the worst OL's in the league. And that is tough on any play caller. Go win the next 2 so we can finish 8-5. I will never be totally down on a 1 score loss to OU, because I can recount the games with them as a little kid where it was 35-7 at half routinely.