Makale Foreman Grad Transfer

I agree with you that the All-American teams are particularly fraught for these purposes. For instance, Niang and Morris had magnificent seasons from a statistical and an efficiency standpoint their senior years, but because the team itself was a Top 20 squad and not a Top 10 one that won many championships, neither of them received much. The AA teams are a lot like the Heisman voting with the same “best player on the best team” bias about them. You need to have some ESPN hype around you, too.

I think that is less true with the all-B12 teams, though, and voting for CPOTY. The voters are much more familiar with the candidates, the schedule is balanced between the teams, and therefore you have a set of voters understanding candidates, choosing from a reasonable number of choices, and do not have the issues for adjusting for scheduling quality.

DeAndre was first-team all-B12 along with Melvin. Even if you were bullish on DeAndre coming into that year, predicting he was going to be voted as one of the five best players in the conference — and undoubtedly deserve it — would have been pretty bullish of you given some of his numbers at Marshall. I really want some investment tips from you going forward if you somehow knew a guy who shot 25% from three in C-USA was going to go toe-to-toe with a handful of future lottery picks for the title of the best guard in the conference and basically come out ahead of them. Saying that guy was going to be better than Marcus Smart would take some brass buttons.

Neither of them received much? Niang was awarded as the top PF in the nation with the Karl Malone award and was a consensus 2nd team AA his senior year and was a 3rd team AA his Junior year.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron