Teams
Forum List
Toggle sidebar

I'll Take Mac over LE

I

isucy86

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
7,634
6,188
113
Dubuque
LE had 2 great years, the next two years were NIT and nothing. LE is a solid coach, but he caught lightning in a bottle with Fizer and Tinsley.

I always felt having LE at coach was like selling your soul to the devil. Sure he put a couple great teams together, but some of the kids he recruited were not the best citizens and I don't feel academics were a big priority.

I believe G-Mac will get ISU to be a Big 12 contender. However, even if he doesn't I'm 100% sure that he'll recruit quality kids.
 
It's a little to early to compare Gmac against Larry. Larry took ISU to a level they have only seen in wrestling, but never any of the major sports. Gmac is about .500 right now.
 
brianhos said:
Larry took ISU to a level they have only seen in wrestling, but never any of the major sports.
Click to expand...

I agree, Brian, plus I think Larry won regular season conference championships in three different leagues. I don't think there is any denying the man can coach. Ever since Orr came to break the ice, we've been able to attract good coaches and Gmac is no exception.
 
Not sure why this is being discussed. Do we have a choice?
 
I honestly cannot believe we are even having this conversation. Eustachy did bring some great times, with Tim Floyd's players.

Mac is in his second season trying to put back a program that was quickly falling apart. He has already brought in a 5 star recruit and if it wasn't for Wesley Johnson's injury and the crazy situation with Staiger we are probably 4-0 right now. Let's wait at least until Johnson is back (who was obviously our best returning player) until we start crying for Mac to leave.
 
bluehooper said:
I honestly cannot believe we are even having this conversation. Eustachy did bring some great times, with Tim Floyd's players.

Mac is in his second season trying to put back a program that was quickly falling apart. He has already brought in a 5 star recruit and if it wasn't for Wesley Johnson's injury and the crazy situation with Staiger we are probably 4-0 right now. Let's wait at least until Johnson is back (who was obviously our best returning player) until we start crying for Mac to leave.
Click to expand...

I agree with the question why are we discussing this. But who in this thread asked for Mac to leave?
 
CAN WE PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, GIVE UP THE LARRY EUSTACHY THREADS HERE ON CF!!!!! IT'S GETTING VERY OLD!!!!!!

P.S. He lives in Mississippi now, if people miss him, move!!!!!!!!!!
 
Landshark said:
CAN WE PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, GIVE UP THE LARRY EUSTACHY THREADS HERE ON CF!!!!! IT'S GETTING VERY OLD!!!!!!

P.S. He lives in Mississippi now, if people miss him, move!!!!!!!!!!
Click to expand...

I agree, we're wasting valuable time that we could be using discussing which of the high level DI head coaching jobs Dan Mc is going to take:rolleyes:
 
LE was a good coach (not great) that left after embarassing the university. He's gone. Let him go. We're on to better things now.
 
My beef with LE (aside from everything that got him fired, which I won't go into again) is that he was JuCo-crazy. Under LE it was JuCo, JuCo, JuCo. JuCo's here, there, everywhere. He was horrible at recruiting high school players. That's entirely the reason he brought in Wayne Morgan, after all, to help him recruit high school talent. The JuCo-crazy route helped plug the holes in the team he inherited from Floyd, and got ISU to the Elite 8, but after that team left we were less than nothing. We were one of the first teams in the NATION to go from first to worst in a conference in 2 seasons, one of the only other major teams to do so being Duke when Krzyzewski left for a sabbatical. This is what JuCo-crazy got us.
 
And how are JuCo's bad? What do you suppose our attrition rate is on High School players in the past 10 years? Simply awful, as it is for every program now. Kids don't sign up for 4 years of role playing anymore. JuCo's don't have that luxury. I'll take my Willoughbys, Catos, Bankheads, Tinsleys, Nurses, Baylisses, Eatons, Pearsons -you can keep your Ramptons, Marsdens, Bristers, Moddermans, etc...

The risk is certainly no higher going Juco anymore, and they don't have the time to transfer, although it still happens... Some if not most of my favorite Cyclones were JuCo's and they were just as much Cyclones as our cherished 4 year players...
 
I agree that it might be too soon to judge; however there two areas I'm concerned with: weak post play and recent recruiting. GMac's forte is coaching the bigs and we have depth and experience - but we've looked pretty weak defending the post and rebounding.

I also think recruiting has cooled off lately; LE, TF, Johnny, and WM all were solid recruiters and they were able to get players from all over the U.S. . We all saw Tom Davis' success using local players; but there is a limit as to how far you can get that way.
 
It seem to me the real point here is we all want to get back to the level of basketball we had when we won back to back Big 12 regular season championships, a tournament championship and go to the elite 8 with Up-Tempo basketball. No doubt, I think everyone wants quality four year kids with a honorable program capable of taking it all the way. Right now even with the talent we have available we don't see the killer instinct or Up-Tempo basketball. I have no doubt with the recruits GMAC is bringing in his teams will be competitive in the future, however, will they be able to finish. When I watch GMAC, I get no sense of the "Eye of the Tiger" that we consistently saw with LE. I really think this is the concern so far. The Bradley game was an example of this, even without Wesley, if we had killer instinct we could have won that game. We saw crisis management in the last minute, where was GMAC in pulling all the stops out three minutes prior to the end? I never sensed that the kids were laying it all out there consistently.
 
I would take Larry any day! At least we had hope under Larry...Sorry to say this but GMAC won't be around in a few years....He's not the right coach for our program.
 
LE using Floyd's players???

Tinsley was brought in by LE and HE not Fizer was the reason we won back to back Big XII Conference titles.
 
VII_Fe said:
LE using Floyd's players???

Tinsley was brought in by LE and HE not Fizer was the reason we won back to back Big XII Conference titles.
Click to expand...


:: UNSHUN ::

I thought you said you weren't going to speak on this site ever again?!?!

:: RESHUN ::
 
Anyone who says we don't have hope for the future with Wesley Johnson, Craig Brackins, Diante Garrett, and (hopefully) Lucca Staiger clearly knows nothing about the game of basketball...These guys are all freshmen and sophomores, and all need to add muscle and knowledge of how to play the game at this level, but once they get it, special things will happen...and who cares whether we play up-tempo basketball or not. I want to see winning basketball. Floyd didn't play up-tempo basketball, and Larry occasionally did, but his teams were based on defense and rebounding. Ask any head coach that has went up against one of McDermott's teams, and they will tell you that this guy knows the game of basketball...I enjoy this site very much, but the bad thing about this being a free public forum is that people with no knowledge of what they are talking about whatsoever, have the same right to offer their uneducated opinions as people who are very much "in the know" on what is going on with ISU athletics. Lately this is looking more and more like a hawkeye message board, with the abundance of eneducated and rediculous comments, backed up with no facts at all.
 
Last edited:
This is a stupid topic to be debating right now. And to whoever said LE could not recruit at the HS level: does Jake Sullivan, Shane Power, Adam Haluska, Jared Homan ring a bell? Yes Power and Haluska left but they were still solid players that LE recruited.

Enough of these LE vs WM vs GMac and DMac vs Chizik threads. It's like a pi$$ing contest and doesn't do any good. Focus on the present and future, what is done in the past has no influence on what happens from here on out.
 
ISUboi12 said:
:: UNSHUN ::

I thought you said you weren't going to speak on this site ever again?!?!

:: RESHUN ::
Click to expand...

I woke up with a bad hangover the other day and said I would never drink again...

8 hours later I was on my way to one hell of a bender.

Sure is nice to know that you care :smile: Besides, with quality people like brainhos my rep level has never looked so good!

NINTENDO STILL BLOWS AND YOU SHOULD GET AN XBOX!
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Help Support Us

Become a patron
Top Bottom
Back