I've been there. The Ranch mafia. And of course, it was PSY who dominated us. But I think he did better with his investigations in that one (in terms of finding mafia members).
***Fantastic Beasts Mafia***
- Thread starter bsaltyman
- Start date
I've been there. The Ranch mafia. And of course, it was PSY who dominated us. But I think he did better with his investigations in that one (in terms of finding mafia members).
If you would have said nothing, we would probably taken a long time to find you. Not sure if PSY would have gone back to investigate somebody he cleared via snickerdoodle.
Also, what exactly did North do that outed him? I went back and looked and only saw Fitzy's post about him using the instakill.
He posted in a different game pm about using an insta kill, there is enough crossover of people that several people here saw it.
If mafia doesn't hit Psy night 1 next game I'm voting for him everyday after that
New mafia strategy. Don't kill psy to make people think that he is mafia.
I will still be voting for him. He can’t be trusted. Whoever the mayor is in the next game puts me in one for PM tandems with him, I am going to be so pissed.
that was really a crazy hour or two. I found myself trying to play mafia essential in not one but two different threads to hide my tracks.
Ok the mafia has agreed to call it a game. CYme was Grindelwald, head of the mafia.
Discy was Queenie, special inno turned mafia.
I hope everyone had fun. Things went south for the mafia faster than I thought. Oh well. Good game everyone!
Discy was Queenie, special inno turned mafia.
I hope everyone had fun. Things went south for the mafia faster than I thought. Oh well. Good game everyone!
Thanks Salty!!Ok the mafia has agreed to call it a game. CYme was Grindelwald, head of the mafia.
Discy was Queenie, special inno turned mafia.
I hope everyone had fun. Things went south for the mafia faster than I thought. Oh well. Good game everyone!
Yep. I saved moores the night he was hit but salty let me know later on that moores also saved himself that night.
I considered going off schedule a couple times by protecting some other players which would have saved them (like hopp) but I didn't want to screw anything up by trying to have more fun with the role.
Gotcha. I was reading and reading trying to figure out what happened. Figured it had to be more than a Fitzy post to make everybody jump on the North train.
So here are my thoughts on the game. I think if we are going to have a special item in the game that saves people and can be passed around, we need less investigative roles. At the end, there were so many cleared innocents that made it next to impossible for mafia to blend in anymore. I think that's quite a few in a row where we have had a special item and the game quickly derailed for mafia. So my thinking is I think we are better off without special items because I think they are unintentionally more powerful than they seem for their dual investigative and healing abilities.
Honestly, if you hadn't lost North and Farnsy the way you did, I thought you would have had a good shot still