Of course I think it’s a good idea. Look what I tried to do day one...... and discy was the only other person who played.....
***Fantastic Beasts Mafia***
- Thread starter bsaltyman
- Start date
Vote Cleaver. Why not vote for mj at that point and give yourself some cushion? It seems like overthinking which typically means a special role and I'm leaning mafia with mj being inno.
Cool, we agree on that. Let's keep it going then. I'm piecing together my list now.
Could have some sort of gimmick where Doug would turn in to Quail Man and gain an instakill or a save or something like that. Like if Patti gets taken out, Doug turns into Qual Man or something.
Obviously since they live in an alternate reality Quailman and Quaildog would be a special teams duo, but end up helping the inno's in the end. See I'm already writing it, but I can't be trusted as a mayor.
My only defense for yesterday is that I was tipped off by a IRL friend playing to switch my vote off myself because I was in danger. That was at 9:04 so I didn’t have time to look through the thread to know what was going on. So legitimately didn’t even know JM was up there when I threw that vote in him. You’ll absolutely waste your time today making this a runaway.
Day 1:
5 - MJ: Vikes 9:07 am, Farnsy 6:11 pm, spiker 7:23 pm, PSY 9:02 pm, Fitzy 9:04 pm
4 - Cleaver: JHUNSY 8:48 am, Cleaver 2:25 pm rescind 9:05 pm, Cubs 6:58 pm, discy 8:14 pm, MJ 8:19 pm
4 - JM: KC 9:13 am, CTown 11:30 am, cyfan21 6:59 pm, discy 7:37 pm rescind 8:14 pm, cleaver 9:05 pm
3 - Clonies: North 8:43 am, Moores 9:47 am, CYme 7:03 pm
2 - Spiker: Clonies 9:50 am, Azhuth 11:11 am, Psy 7:01 pm rescind 9:02 pm
2 - PSY: JM 8:13 am, MeowingCows 12:31 pm
2 - KC: SCNCY 8:58 am, michael 6:36 pm
1 - Fitzy: Cyfan13 8:56 am
1 - SaraV: Cyhiphopp 9:15 am
1 - Cyhiphopp: SaraV 2:20 pm
0 - Cyfan13: Fitzy 2:27 pm rescind 9:04 pm
0 - North: MJ 9:31 am rescind 8:19 pm
0 - Farnsy: CYme 9:28 am rescind 7:02 pm
0 - Discy: Discy 12:00 pm rescind 3:21 pm
Not wanting to be a stickler because it can piss people off, but gonna do it anyway:
Private communication among non-mafia is a no-no unless their roles call for it (none of them do this game), and is why I nudged the n00b yesterday in thread to get a vote in. That brought a bit of heat down on me.
Also, if Fitzy hasn't been offed by the mafia on the first night, he's either protected or mafia.
That said, I'm going to watch for a bit and see how the Cleaver-Fitzy grudge match progresses.
Private communication among non-mafia is a no-no unless their roles call for it (none of them do this game), and is why I nudged the n00b yesterday in thread to get a vote in. That brought a bit of heat down on me.
Also, if Fitzy hasn't been offed by the mafia on the first night, he's either protected or mafia.
That said, I'm going to watch for a bit and see how the Cleaver-Fitzy grudge match progresses.
I agree, the offed by mafia part, but Fitzy put a target on his back last night and if he isn't mafia then that is a narrative that would be easy for mafia to push.