***Fantastic Beasts Mafia***
- Thread starter bsaltyman
- Start date
I want to give him the benefit of the doubt but he's making it harder to do that
As an FYI, the Doctor is immune to mafia hits through night 5. At this point it would probably be worthwhile for the Doctor to let me know who they are so I don't waste an investigation on them.
So he/she has three more days (two night phases) to out him or herself?
In the interim, if the doctor protects me tonight you can just send the tabernacle back to me and we can protect ourselves.
1) quiet
2) didn't answer my question about getting behind on his PMs
3) that's about it
My rationale is the 'dang' message yesterday after my save. Though it could certainly have been in regards to Az being inno...
Here's why I lean inno on a couple of folks:
CYme -
He voted for me this morning; at this point it seems pretty clear mafia would have discussed in their chat at some point that I was a special inno and he would have seen that and NOT voted for me
cyfan21 -
He voted for JHUNSY at 6:57pm.
At 4:16pm JHUNSY made his not-at-all-obvious hint as to his role and at 4:52 SaraV spelled it out pretty dang clearly for everyone. Between 4:16pm and 6:57pm I have to think SOMEONE in the mafia chat would have brought up JHUNSY potentially being a special inno. And if that's the case, cyfan21 would have seen it and not voted for him.
Obviously there could be some people playing dumb about that. But I'm leaning inno on these two for those reasons.
CYme -
He voted for me this morning; at this point it seems pretty clear mafia would have discussed in their chat at some point that I was a special inno and he would have seen that and NOT voted for me
cyfan21 -
He voted for JHUNSY at 6:57pm.
At 4:16pm JHUNSY made his not-at-all-obvious hint as to his role and at 4:52 SaraV spelled it out pretty dang clearly for everyone. Between 4:16pm and 6:57pm I have to think SOMEONE in the mafia chat would have brought up JHUNSY potentially being a special inno. And if that's the case, cyfan21 would have seen it and not voted for him.
Obviously there could be some people playing dumb about that. But I'm leaning inno on these two for those reasons.
This is something I keep coming back to. Farnsy has a reputation of not playing and getting clapped. Now he's posting more often and making excuses for not being able to post more.
I don't know if that means anything other than he has rediscovered his joy of mafia or what.
You would think that mafia members would read their chats and vote accordingly. But I've played a few games where people didn't read the chat/forgot what was discussed/etc. So I guess what I'm saying is I buy the CYme angle, but the cyfan21 angle is a bit thinner. Probably only because of the tight time window.
Day 2 vote count before North f***ed up
4 - Cleaver: Discy 9:19 am, North 9:27 am, Vikes 9:59 am, cyfan21 10:38.
3 - Fitzy: Moores 8:14 am, Cyfan13 9:06 am, Farnsy 9:08 am
2 - PSY: CTown 8:13 am, JM 8:28 am
1 - JHUNSY: Hiphopp 8:43 am
1 - Discy: spiker 8:08 am
4 - Cleaver: Discy 9:19 am, North 9:27 am, Vikes 9:59 am, cyfan21 10:38.
3 - Fitzy: Moores 8:14 am, Cyfan13 9:06 am, Farnsy 9:08 am
2 - PSY: CTown 8:13 am, JM 8:28 am
1 - JHUNSY: Hiphopp 8:43 am
1 - Discy: spiker 8:08 am
I like this more than the noob vote and KC, although I’m usually not right about her, needs company up top.
vote farnsy
This would have been a bold statement for a mafia member to make after Fitzy said North was mafia.
FWIW, farnsy is also playing the other CF game and could have seen North's message.