At 125, I believe Joey Fio of Oklahoma should receive strong consideration for the #1 Seed. His record against the other four starters in the Big 12 is 3-1, just like Donahoe of Nebraska (Returning National Champ). Fio did lose to Ashmore of Oklahoma St, who is not with the team anymore. Fio beat Donahoe head to head. Fio's only loss to the starters is Tyler Clark.
If the seedings fall as they should at 125, here is how they will look.
#1 Joey Fio - Oklahoma
#4 Tyler Clark - Iowa State
#5 John Olanowski - Missouri
#2 Paul Donahoe - Nebraska
#3 Tyler Shinn - Oklahoma St.
This would give Tyler Clark a great chance to reach finals and lock up a spot at Nationals. If they give Donahoe the #1 seed, Clark will have Donahoe in the semis and have to beat Shinn/Fio loser to stay in top 3.
If the seedings fall as they should at 125, here is how they will look.
#1 Joey Fio - Oklahoma
#4 Tyler Clark - Iowa State
#5 John Olanowski - Missouri
#2 Paul Donahoe - Nebraska
#3 Tyler Shinn - Oklahoma St.
This would give Tyler Clark a great chance to reach finals and lock up a spot at Nationals. If they give Donahoe the #1 seed, Clark will have Donahoe in the semis and have to beat Shinn/Fio loser to stay in top 3.