I watched Bottle Rocket maybe 3-4 years after it came out. I didn’t follow movies, so I didn’t know who WA was. I liked BR quite a bit. Saw RT shortly after and really liked it. Frankly at the time I still had no idea who WA was or that he did both movies.
When Life Aquatic came out I thought I’d love it. Same guy that did RT, Bill Murray, etc. I found zero entertainment in Life Aquatic.
For some reason RT really resonates with me. I think the characters are great, the acting is great, and there’s no character in a movie that I wanted to redeem himself more than Hackman’s Royal.
I’m not sure why, but I found Life Aquatic to be Way less funny and I did not care about the characters. To me it had the quirkiness of RT but pretty much little else.