Halloween candy GOAT

Best Halloween candy?

  • Reeces

    Votes: 98 38.9%
  • Twix

    Votes: 12 4.8%
  • Snickers

    Votes: 47 18.7%
  • KitKat

    Votes: 18 7.1%
  • Butterfinger

    Votes: 21 8.3%
  • Baby Ruth

    Votes: 8 3.2%
  • Almond Joy

    Votes: 12 4.8%
  • Milky Way

    Votes: 9 3.6%
  • Mr Goodbar

    Votes: 4 1.6%
  • Other

    Votes: 23 9.1%

  • Total voters
    252
Don't get me wrong, I love candy bars 365. Smarties are a Halloween tradition! Seriously can you even find them at a gas station?
 
Nerds hit different on Halloween for some reason
Try Nerds gummy clusters. Thank me later.
Why its all the same damn thing? You are strange pal.
Holiday ones are fresher.
Other: 100 Grand
This. Always this.
Smarties are amazing
Original Sixlets are amazing-er. The new ones have a weird tasting coating, though.
Cherry Mash? Never heard of that sounds interesting.
These are made in St Joseph,MO, and appear to be a very nostalgic candy to a lot of people here in KC. I've had one before. I thought it was terrible. It's like if you told a 5 year old to try make a Twin Bing and he did the best he could do.
Wtf is a Mr Goodbar
It's those yellow-wrapped miniature candy bars that are left in the bag of assorted chocolates after everyone eats the good stuff.
 
Just bought 2 big bags of Almond Joy for 2 trick or treaters we get...leftovers are a b***h. Country living has some advantages :).
 
No mention of Hot Tamales or Mike and Ike’s! I’ve seen Hot Tamales get a lot of hate online, and California is trying to get them to change their ingredients, but I love them. They’re never included in those big variety packs anymore either.

Dots are great too. And I’m also one of the freaks who likes Almond Joys too!
 
  • Like
Reactions: stateofmind
Wtf is a Mr Goodbar

Hershey bar w some peanuts

Absolutely delicious Hershey bar with some peanuts, I think you meant to say

Isn't that called a Mr. Good bar?
wtf-what-the-f-uck.gif
And I can't take Reeces as a vote as it's spelled wrong. And all the people trying to convince others and spelling it other ways are invalid. Bet some of you pronounce it REE sees. It's Reese's, so I voted for Almond Joy. Suck it CyCrazy.

 
Last edited:
Try Nerds gummy clusters. Thank me later.

Holiday ones are fresher.

This. Always this.

Original Sixlets are amazing-er. The new ones have a weird tasting coating, though.

These are made in St Joseph,MO, and appear to be a very nostalgic candy to a lot of people here in KC. I've had one before. I thought it was terrible. It's like if you told a 5 year old to try make a Twin Bing and he did the best he could do.

It's those yellow-wrapped miniature candy bars that are left in the bag of assorted chocolates after everyone eats the good stuff.

Oh I’m semi addicted to them
 
No mention of Hot Tamales or Mike and Ike’s! I’ve seen Hot Tamales get a lot of hate online, and California is trying to get them to change their ingredients, but I love them. They’re never included in those big variety packs anymore either.

Dots are great too. And I’m also one of the freaks who likes Almond Joys too!
Hot Tamales and Mike and Ike’s lost their way when they went to plastic bags over the boxes. Very much like nerds, they are meant to be eaten by dumping candy into your mouth. I do not want to pick them out of a bag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Drew0311

Help Support Us

Become a patron