F*CK IOWA
- Thread starter FallOf81
- Start date
Yep, correct. Takes away all the buzz of the “return” as the degree of difficultly was quite low given 6 players were instantly out of the play, by their own doing (i.e. slowing down, making basically 0 effort to actually tackle as they assumed play was about to be dead). I about puked when CW posted something about a comparison to Reggie Bush.
@CYFanKC what was dumb about my post. They didn't whistle forward progress which wouldn't be reviewable they whistled down by contact.
Big 12 on Texas fumble: 'No indisputable evidence'
After a controversial end to Thursday night's game, the conference issues a statement.
www.sbnation.com
Come on. What in the hell would the NCAA national coordinator of officials know about the NCAA rules?
Why should Hok fans listen to that putz when they can do their own research.
Are you sure that "scoring play" wasn't the reason that the play was reviewed since it was at the time of the review, you know, a scoring play?
I'm not sure if it was two 15 yarders but ISU was assessed two penalties on one play in the Iowa State Iowa game a last year that got Iowa into field goal range for the potentially game winning FG but Iowa missed it.
The other hand Einstein.
KidSilverhair
Well-Known Member
I keep seeing references to “all scoring plays are reviewed” or even one comment about “they review all plays in the last 2 minutes.”
Folks, you’re confusing college and NFL rules. In the NFL, the booth reviews all scoring plays, turnovers, and anything in the last 2 minutes of each half. Coaches have a couple of challenges they can use at the risk of losing a time out if they’re wrong.
In college, all plays can be reviewed at any time. The replay official can buzz the on-field officials to stop the game and take a look at every play, if they think there’s a question about ball placement/dead ball/possession/catch/etc. Do they give scoring plays and turnovers extra attention? Most likely, yes, but they’re not limited to those. I think there’s still a coach’s challenge rule in college football, too, but that’s rarely used any more.
Folks, you’re confusing college and NFL rules. In the NFL, the booth reviews all scoring plays, turnovers, and anything in the last 2 minutes of each half. Coaches have a couple of challenges they can use at the risk of losing a time out if they’re wrong.
In college, all plays can be reviewed at any time. The replay official can buzz the on-field officials to stop the game and take a look at every play, if they think there’s a question about ball placement/dead ball/possession/catch/etc. Do they give scoring plays and turnovers extra attention? Most likely, yes, but they’re not limited to those. I think there’s still a coach’s challenge rule in college football, too, but that’s rarely used any more.
Let's hope this costume is good for another year or two . . . .
What on earth would make you think an Hok poster has any connection to academics in Iowa City?
In fairness, TPTB told us that the officials go the call right (after they incorrectly did NOT stop play for a dead ball) for the "Phantom 3" at the Phog.
KidSilverhair
Well-Known Member
That’s one that still makes me scratch my head. “Yes, the officials should have stopped them from going downcourt and making that shot, but since they didn’t, guess there’s nothing we can do, no way to retroactively take those points off the board once KU scored them, play stands.“
Basically the same thing as “nothing in the rulebook says a dog can’t play basketball.”
If you knew more about them, you'd probably change careers for one of those medical sales jobs.
I bet they would still review it to make sure he didn't step OB, then assess the fair catch call, which btw, is still the correct call
KidSilverhair
Well-Known Member
Yep, as I said above, this notion that they only reviewed it because DeJean scored, and if he hadn’t made it to the end zone they wouldn’t have been able to, is false. College officials can review any play they think needs another look.
No Hok posters yet today. What is going on? My daily dose of "wisdom" is needed.
You have to give some of these Iowa fans time to finally get tired and wear down -- like you do with a spoiled brat who throws a hissy fit after being told he can't have a toy