That's total ********. They tried something different. They tried going under center. They tried huddling up. They tried simplifying reads.
Just because the end result was virtually the same does not mean the journey was.
Please also tell us about all of the OCs who have been fired this year and what their success was relative to the current year of output. I'm going to go out on a limb and guess Manning is calling the exact game Campbell wants called. Manning's track record is pretty damn solid at this point in time. This year is by no means good...but the last few years have been pretty damn good.
Matt Campbell doesn't want the Texas Tech/Oklahoma/etc. offenses of scoring 45 and hoping to only give up 42. He shouldn't want that because we likely can't win playing that way. He wants us to give up 20 and score 24 by playing keep away from high octane offenses. Again...not good this year...but his track record is pretty damn good.
Long story short...Matt Campbell has had a pretty solid tenure at Iowa State and I would guess he knows a bit more about how he wants his program to look than some ass clowns on a message board. His way has yielded a program that isn't a national embarrassment so whatever he feels like doing should be a-ok with the fans.