Teams
Forum List
Toggle sidebar

Does Kurt Warner Make It...

helechopper

helechopper

Loyal Son Forever True
Apr 8, 2006
5,302
5,001
113
Chicago
into the Pro Football Hall of Fame? And if he does, will he be a first ballot inductee?

I say yes, he's a 3-time Pro Bowler, 2-time first-team All-Pro and a Super Bowl champ/MVP.

Not to mention he has a pretty damn good shot at making the Super Bowl this year.

Dude just never quits.
 
I have honestly never been a big fan of his. Maybe it's because he played a huge part of knocking my Eagles out in the NFC championship game in 2002. And I got sick of all of the hype he got throughout that whole time period, and his time period with the Rams. And that feeling will only grow stronger if he knocks the Eagles out again next week (if they can get past the Giants tomorrow).

All of that being said, it would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, to call him a first ballot inductee. He hasn't had that long of a career, but he's done more in a short amount of time than nearly any QB in NFL history. He's got the numbers and the accolades that make him a no brainer inductee...
 
If he wins the Super Bowl again can you keep him out? Its too bad he had those rough years where he didnt get a chance after the 2nd Super Bowl.
 
You also have to remember all the stats in the Arena Football League as well. Not sure about first year on the ballot but i am sure he will get in. Which is good because I have like 3 of his autographs.
 
He definitely is a HOF and after winning 2 playoff games with the Cardinals he should be a first ballot guy now.
 
I think he makes the HOF but not on his first ballot. The guy averages 262 yards a game. He has only played 3 seasons where he has played all 16 games. four of his seasons he has played single digit games. I would say that he is one of the most productive QBs out there for the amount of time he has played. He is 37 and has 11 years of experience with only 10 games played.
 
How about Trent Dilfet, Brad Johnson, Doug Williams? They have also won the Super Bowl

My answer is no. He had a great stretch for a few years, but for a good portion of his career he was a backup. I don't think he sustained the great years long enough to be a Hall of Famer
 
To Todd Blythe and his current sitution, remember Kurt was sacking groceries at Hy-Vee in CF when he was given a break.
 
I think if he makes the Super Bowl this year and has another productive year or two, he makes it. It is the hall of "fame" as he definitely has his place in history. If it ends now he is marginal.
 
Definately, the guy is a great ball player. everyone was writing him off after going to the Cardinals and now look at them. He's won two Super Bowls was a league MVP twice and Super Bowl MVP as well. Eventually he will get in, first ballot maybe.
 
cmoneyr said:
I say not near enough consistency to be a HOF qb. It's not the Hall of Good Players, there should be a higher standard to get into the HOF.
Click to expand...

Warner has the 2nd highest QB rating (career) of all time. How's that not consistant?

List of QBs with over 50, 300 yard passing games:

Marino (67) - HOF
Favre (58) - lock for the HOF
Fouts (56) - HOF
Moon (53) - HOF
Manning (53) - lock for the HOF
Warner (52) - ???

Above Montana, Elway, Young, & Unitas and DOUBLE what Super-tom-Brady has right now.
 
Last edited:
He needs to make more commercials. He need sto get his name out there more on the two coasts.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Help Support Us

Become a patron
Top Bottom