All Iowa Football Team---Post Bowl Edition

[Brodie0]

I'll give credit for Goodson having a very good game against Minnesota. You will not see me ranting and raving for him racking up 26 yards on 5 carries against Wisconsin, or 16 yards on 3 carries against ISU, or 35 yards on 8 carries against Penn State. He also had a huge fumble in the Penn State game that hurt Iowa big time. Spare me the stud comment.

He was a good freshman RB last year. But you're comparing him to the literal best freshman RB in the nation last year.

Hall played against almost exclusively terrible defenses last season. In the games he played against good defenses, he sucked. He seems like he is going to be a really good player, but I’m not going to anoint him as some superstar without seeing him perform well against a good defense.

Luckily, with the Iowa game getting cancelled, Iowa State likely won’t be facing many good defenses next season, so Hall (and the rest of Iowa State’s offense) can continue to rack up stats against the worst P5 defenses in college football.

 

[CyTwins]

Hall played against almost exclusively terrible defenses last season. In the games he played against good defenses, he sucked. He seems like he is going to be a really good player, but I’m not going to anoint him as some superstar without seeing him perform well against a good defense.

So All American Heflin played against good offenses?

Also you don't have to be a superstar to be better than Tyler Goodson. He's fine but he's small and slow

 

[Brodie0]

Just a couple months ago you said LaPorta was better than Allen. What changed over the last couple months to put Allen on your all-Iowa team instead of LaPorta?

Bump for @CyTwins

 

[TrianglePlace]

QB- Purdy
RB- Hall
RB- Goodson
WR- Smith- Marsette
WR- Milton
TE- Kolar
OL- Jackson
OL- Downing
OL- Linderbaum
OL- Cronk
OL- Kallenberger

DL- Golston
DL- Nixon
DL- Heflin
DL- Bailey
LB- Rose
LB- Vance
LB- Colbert
CB- Hankins
CB- Johnson
S- Eisworth
S- Koerner

K- Duncan
KR- Smith- Marsette
P- ISU Punter

 

[CyTwins]

Bump for @CyTwins

I think Allen is better than LaPorta. Allen is third team Athlon All Conference. The "most talented DL in the state" is fourth team!

 

[CyTwins]

QB- Purdy
RB- Hall
RB- Goodson
WR- Smith- Marsette
WR- Milton
TE- Kolar
OL- Jackson
OL- Downing
OL- Linderbaum
OL- Cronk
OL- Kallenberger

DL- Golston
DL- Nixon
DL- Heflin
DL- Bailey
LB- Rose
LB- Vance
LB- Colbert
CB- Hankins
CB- Johnson
S- Eisworth
S- Koerner

K- Duncan
KR- Smith- Marsette
P- ISU Punter

I don't agree with your OL and DL

Koerner over White is just silly

 

[Brodie0]

I think Allen is better than LaPorta. Allen is third team Athlon All Conference. The "most talented DL in the state" is fourth team!

So what happened over the last couple months to make you change your mind? You claimed LaPorta was better than Allen just a couple months ago.

 

[Statefan10]

Hall played against almost exclusively terrible defenses last season. In the games he played against good defenses, he sucked. He seems like he is going to be a really good player, but I’m not going to anoint him as some superstar without seeing him perform well against a good defense.

Luckily, with the Iowa game getting cancelled, Iowa State likely won’t be facing many good defenses next season, so Hall (and the rest of Iowa State’s offense) can continue to rack up stats against the worst P5 defenses in college football.

Tell me which games he sucked.. The Iowa game where he got 1 touch or was it the TCU game where he got 1 touch?

 

[Statefan10]

QB- Purdy
RB- Hall
RB- Goodson
WR- Smith- Marsette
WR- Milton
TE- Kolar
OL- Jackson
OL- Downing
OL- Linderbaum
OL- Cronk
OL- Kallenberger

DL- Golston
DL- Nixon
DL- Heflin
DL- Bailey
LB- Rose
LB- Vance
LB- Colbert
CB- Hankins
CB- Johnson
S- Eisworth
S- Koerner

K- Duncan
KR- Smith- Marsette
P- ISU Punter

Is Koerner going to be okay this season?

 

[jmb]

That’s not why I put Heflin on the team. I put Heflin on the team because he is a better DT than anyone Iowa State has to offer. @jmb is the one that thinks Heflin should automatically be on the team because he was a PFF All-American.

You really struggle. Troll.

 

[CyTwins]

So what happened over the last couple months to make you change your mind? You claimed LaPorta was better than Allen just a couple months ago.

The fact Athlon had Allen 3rd team which is better than the most talented DL in the state made me realize I am underestimating how good Allen is

 

[Brodie0]

You really struggle. Troll.

That’s one way to wave the white flag.

 

[jmb]

Is Goodson over Hall the new Stanley over Purdy? Lol



Hall:

First-Team True Freshman All-American – 247Sports (2019)
First-Team All-Freshman Team – PFF (2019)
Second-Team Freshman All-American – The Athletic (2019)
Second-Team All-Big 12 - Coaches (2019)

Goodson:












...

@Brodie0

 

[CyTwins]

You've referred to Heflin as an All American multiple times so I'll ask again:

Is PFF credible?

Bump for @Brodie0

 

[jmb]

Thats one way to wave the white flag.

The flag I am waving is white with black because I win again. Thank you @CyTwins for the link showing bro-d what's up.

 

[Brodie0]

The flag I am waving is white with black because I win again. Thank you @CyTwins for the link showing bro-d what's up.

So All-American status only matters if your name is Breece Hall, but not if your name is Jack Heflin. Makes a lot of sense. Thanks for clarifying.

 

[Brodie0]

Bump for @Brodie0

Yes it’s credible, but I’m not going to base my opinions solely off PFF.

 

[jmb]

So All-American status only matters if your name is Breece Hall, but not if your name is Jack Heflin. Makes a lot of sense. Thanks for clarifying.

Did not talk about Jack Heflin jackass.

 

[CyTwins]

Yes it’s credible, but I’m not going to base my opinions solely off PFF.

I mean you're saying someone with no accolades is better than a first team All American. Lol cmon man you can't be that dumb

 

[Statefan10]

Tell me which games he sucked.. The Iowa game where he got 1 touch or was it the TCU game where he got 1 touch?

Bump @Brodie0