Iowa Football Recruiting

How can it be a wash if your starter is better than ours? Our backups/depth is just better?

I don’t think Goodson is way better than Hall. It’s pretty close. I think Brock has a higher ceiling than Sargent, although Sargent would probably put up pretty big numbers in the Big XII. He’s been really good against bad defenses throughout his career, he’s just not dynamic enough against the elite defenses like Michigan, Penn State, Wisconsin, etc. He’d probably be a 1,200 yard rusher in the Big XII.
 
Let's compare the two's accolades

Breece Hall:

First-Team True Freshman All-American – 247Sports (2019)
First-Team All-Freshman Team – PFF (2019)
Second-Team Freshman All-American – The Athletic (2019)
Second-Team All-Big 12 - Coaches (2019)

Tyler Goodson:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stewo
Now you're down Wirfs who was your best OL by far. Goodson was never that good when I saw him play. He isn't very big and he's not fast

They will have at least some practice to prepare for Wirfs. They only had a week to prepare for the loss of Jackson, and were playing a team that had used the entire off season to prepare for their super bowl. Even going as far as to put a countdown clock in their locker room.

****Note**** The first 23 words of this post are factual and represent my actual opinion of the circumstances that played out last year. The last 32 words were an attempt to troll various posters on this board and shouldn’t be taken seriously.
 
Let's compare the two's accolades

Breece Hall:

First-Team True Freshman All-American – 247Sports (2019)
First-Team All-Freshman Team – PFF (2019)
Second-Team Freshman All-American – The Athletic (2019)
Second-Team All-Big 12 - Coaches (2019)

Tyler Goodson:

Freshman accolades in the Big XII don’t mean much. Didn’t Mike Warren put up monster stats his freshman year? Turns out he wasn’t very good.
 
Do you think CMC has thought about putting that on a trophy so Iowa State’s trophy case isn’t so empty?

No. It just makes you sound even more dumb when you think someone who was nothing is better than an All American when the All Americans team faced a much tougher schedule
 
Last time I checked, 5’10”, 200 is bigger than 6’1”, 205.
tenor.gif
 
No. It just makes you sound even more dumb when you think someone who was nothing is better than an All American when the All Americans team faced a much tougher schedule

What would you have said to someone who said Leshun Daniels and Akrum Wadley were better than Mike Warren after Warren’s freshman year?
 
What would you have said to someone who said Leshun Daniels and Akrum Wadley were better than Mike Warren after Warren’s freshman year?

No clue. Warren was on a bad team that could actually run block though. He was built for Rhoads offense and struggled with a new blocking scheme. Not sure how that compares to Hall or even Brock when Iowa desperately wanted both of them in their RB room
 
Freshman accolades in the Big XII don’t mean much. Didn’t Mike Warren put up monster stats his freshman year? Turns out he wasn’t very good.
Yeah and a guy that came in after Mike was a beast.
This is a dumb post by you but not suprising.
 
No clue. Warren was on a bad team that could actually run block though. He was built for Rhoads offense and struggled with a new blocking scheme. Not sure how that compares to Hall or even Brock when Iowa desperately wanted both of them in their RB room

Daniels is better than Wadley I assume since he's the starter. Warren is clearly better than both

Because you apparently thought Warren was better than Daniels and Wadley based off the stats he racked up against terrible defenses. Now you are claiming Breece Hall is better than Goodson based off the stats he racked up against terrible defenses. I’ve already showed you how much better Goodson did against good defenses. You can claim Goodson had a good OL and Hall didn’t, and that’s fair. But sorry I’m not impressed by Hall lighting up the terrible defenses he faced and barely managing to crack 3 yards per carry against the good defenses.
 
Because you apparently thought Warren was better than Daniels and Wadley based off the stats he racked up against terrible defenses. Now you are claiming Breece Hall is better than Goodson based off the stats he racked up against terrible defenses. I’ve already showed you how much better Goodson did against good defenses. You can claim Goodson had a good OL and Hall didn’t, and that’s fair. But sorry I’m not impressed by Hall lighting up the terrible defenses he faced and barely managing to crack 3 yards per carry against the good defenses.

Is that your "gotcha" moment? You said Stanley was better than Purdy. Hell even today you said Iowa's TE's were better than Iowa State's when we have Kolar, Allen and Soehner lol
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron