Teams
Forum List
Toggle sidebar

Iowa Football Recruiting

TRYHARDER said:
I don't agree. Bollers would be the highest rated recruit that Campbell has landed since coming to ISU. I don't think it's even very close.
Click to expand...
The last three years they have landed four stars that were .90 to .91 (round to two decimals). So it's not like we are talking upper 90's and as CMC gains more steam as coaching it would only make sense he starts getting better four star guys. I don't see how you don't see that
 
SouthernCy said:
The last three years they have landed four stars that were .90 to .91 (round to two decimals). So it's not like we are talking upper 90's and as CMC gains more steam as coaching it would only make sense he starts getting better four star guys. I don't see how you don't see that
Click to expand...

How about addressing my original point way back when. I said that getting this many 0 P5 offer kids is not a good sign. I asked how many 0 P5 guys CMC has had success with and I get lists of Rhoads recruits, guys with 1 other P5 offer, and then a bunch of silence.

The point is CMC has had the most success with guys who have other P5 offers. The vast majority of school have the most success with guys like that. Bollers has other offers, a few of your guys have other offers. Yet the majority don't and that is not a good sign, no matter how you try to re paint that picture.
 
Legend Hawk said:
How about addressing my original point way back when. I said that getting this many 0 P5 offer kids is not a good sign. I asked how many 0 P5 guys CMC has had success with and I get lists of Rhoads recruits, guys with 1 other P5 offer, and then a bunch of silence.

The point is CMC has had the most success with guys who have other P5 offers. The vast majority of school have the most success with guys like that. Bollers has other offers, a few of your guys have other offers. Yet the majority don't and that is not a good sign, no matter how you try to re paint that picture.
Click to expand...

You realize more offers are going to come right?
 
CyTwins said:
You realize more offers are going to come right?
Click to expand...

Some might, some might not. The question is CMC has given out 200 offers or so, why isn't he winning the recruiting battle for more guys that actually had options outside of ISU?
 
Legend Hawk said:
Some might, some might not. The question is CMC has given out 200 offers or so, why isn't he winning the recruiting battle for more guys that actually had options outside of ISU?
Click to expand...

You don't know what his big board looks like. We have a WR with a Michigan offer that wants to come here and we're passing on him
 
CyTwins said:
You don't know what his big board looks like. We have a WR with a Michigan offer that wants to come here and we're passing on him
Click to expand...

You have no idea what his "big board" looks like either. Even you understand that guys with other P5 options have a vastly greater chance of panning out then guys without P5 offers.
 
TheBear said:
I agree with SouthernCy that rankings and offers don’t matter all that much. The thing is clone fans tie a huge amount of their identity to such things as false proof that isu is becoming what they hope and pray for. Would this thread really have more than 36,000 posts it it wasn’t life or death to clone fans?
Click to expand...
Most of the posts are from obsessed Iowa fans. The rest are from Cyclone fans showing you how stupid you hawk fans are. It's funny, but also a little sad how much the IQ of our state drops the further east you go.
 
CyTwins said:
You don't know what his big board looks like. We have a WR with a Michigan offer that wants to come here and we're passing on him
Click to expand...

and there it is. CyTwins has daily access not only to Iowa’s recruiting board but isu’s as well. So do the isu coaches have a daily call with you to tell you who they really want and who they are passing on?

Amazing that CyTwins has time to meet with Iowa and isu coaches on a daily basis to review the recruiting board in addition to all the work he does as a “friend of the family” for past, current and future Iowa & isu recruits and still have all this time to do all the posting he does here.
 
Legend Hawk said:
You have no idea what his "big board" looks like either. Even you understand that guys with other P5 options have a vastly greater chance of panning out then guys without P5 offers.
Click to expand...

I mean it's not like I all of a sudden think better about Silas because TCU offered after he committed
 
adjl said:
Most of the posts are from obsessed Iowa fans. The rest are from Cyclone fans showing you how stupid you hawk fans are. It's funny, but also a little sad how much the IQ of our state drops the further east you go.
Click to expand...

So why are clone fans posting so much about rankings and offers if they really don’t matter?
 
CyTwins said:
I mean it's not like I all of a sudden think better about Silas because TCU offered after he committed
Click to expand...

So you don't think offer lists matter then? We both know that CMC has done way better with kids that had good offer list (see Purdy) over bad offer lists (see Zed Nolan).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Help Support Us

Become a patron
Top Bottom