Everyone in the top 6 won fairly decisively except FSU

SmellyTP

Member
Feb 28, 2014
53
0
6
34
Not even sure the Big 12 will have ANY team considering what OSU just did to Wisconsin. FSU is still unbeaten and are the ACC champs, so they're in. Bama and Oregon are champs so they're in.

1. Bama
2. Oregon
3. OSU
4. FSU
5. TCU
6. Baylor
 
Last edited:
Re: Everyone in the top 6 won fairly decisively except OSU

FSU won 37-35, I don't call that decisive. I wouldn't call the Baylor win decisive either. I think you have your title wrong - it should be FSU.
 
Not sure TCU could have stayed in even if they had beaten us bad. As in bad. When you beat the worst team in the FBS, what does it really mean?
 
Not sure TCU could have stayed in even if they had beaten us bad. As in bad. When you beat the worst team in the FBS, what does it really mean?

I know what you mean, but it sure sounds funny when they just beat us by 52 and held us to 3 points.
 
I know what you mean, but it sure sounds funny when they just beat us by 52 and held us to 3 points.

Ah yes, the 3 points. OSU had a shutout and TCU did not. I think the votes for B12 may be divided and they will not have a team. Thanks, Netten.
 
Of course the Big 10 sucks. The media doesn't care. The selection committee may not care either.

It looks like two crap conferences, (i.e. BIG and ACC) will have reps out of the four. What happens if the hearing for Winston kicks him out of the big games?
 
I just don't see OSU getting the jump over TCU. call it love for the underdog or whatever, but to me, the loss to Baylor is less of a blemish than OSU's loss to VT. This being said, the CFP is as crooked as a Pikes Peak, so TCU will likely get shafted. I think that before TCU slides though, FSU would slide out. Remember, FSU has faced the weakest schedule of any team in the top 6. just my 2 cents.
 
TCU was 3 this week and OSU wasn't because TCU lost to the #6 team on a bad call in the final minutes and OSU lost to a horrid Va Tech team. Those facts didn't change this week. The Big 12 is 1 or 2 in just about every conference ranking out there, the Big 10 is 4th at best. I expect the committee to send the message that if you lose to a ****** team you don't get to make it up by blowing out a mediocre team in a championship game.
 
Anybody looking at the entire body of work is going to realize the B1G is a suckfest. I can't see them putting OSU in over TCU.
 
I just don't see OSU getting the jump over TCU. call it love for the underdog or whatever, but to me, the loss to Baylor is less of a blemish than OSU's loss to VT. This being said, the CFP is as crooked as a Pikes Peak, so TCU will likely get shafted. I think that before TCU slides though, FSU would slide out. Remember, FSU has faced the weakest schedule of any team in the top 6. just my 2 cents.

OSU just beat the #13 team in the country with their 3rd-string quarterback. The Semioles are the defending national champs and are the only remaining undefeated team in the country. Last year they broke the SEC's streak of 7 straight national championships. To suggest that they should be left out of the playoff is really pushing it to the limit.
 
TCU was 3 this week and OSU wasn't because TCU lost to the #6 team on a bad call in the final minutes and OSU lost to a horrid Va Tech team. Those facts didn't change this week. The Big 12 is 1 or 2 in just about every conference ranking out there, the Big 10 is 4th at best. I expect the committee to send the message that if you lose to a ****** team you don't get to make it up by blowing out a mediocre team in a championship game.

You apparently assume committee members rely on facts and not gut feelings.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron