Misc: Who was the greatest golfer of all time?

Who was/is the greatest golfer ever?

  • Eldrick (Tiger)

    Votes: 64 63.4%
  • The Golden Bear ( Nicklaus)

    Votes: 17 16.8%
  • Arnie (Palmer)

    Votes: 1 1.0%
  • Bobby Jones

    Votes: 5 5.0%
  • Walter Hagen

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Iron Byron

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sam Snead

    Votes: 4 4.0%
  • Brianhos

    Votes: 7 6.9%
  • Ben Hogan

    Votes: 3 3.0%

  • Total voters
    101

cyismydog

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2006
6,340
213
63
Just figured I'd get this started. I'm torn between three, Tiger, the Golden Bear, and Bobby Jones.
The reason Bobby is on this list is because he was dominant, and golf wasn't even his day job.
 
Why is Tiger apart of this list.. he is still playing.

Who was the greatest golfer? Sam Snead or Old Country Tom.

-keep
 
This may be a bit of a cop out on my end, but, it's really hard to pick one. I think each one was great in their respective time, but, to say "Greatest, it's really hard to compare. What would tiger do with cast iron irons and wooden shafts. What would Bobby Jones have done with todays equipment. Even training methods. People really underestimate the power of video and computer technology and how it has helped people "perfect" a swing. Who knows how dominant an older player might have been or on the flip side, how dominant a rival may have been that was just missing that little something extra.

I really don't follow golf that closely. I watch here and there. I know names and I play. So, if I had to pick. I'd say Tiger. The guy really is amazing to watch and to be honest, I never really got to watch anyone else.
 
I'm gonna go with Babe Didrikson Zaharias...the first woman to compete with men's PGA event. But not only that; she was a triple medal winner in track and field at the Olympics, and an All-American in basketball.
 
What would tiger do with cast iron irons and wooden shafts. What would Bobby Jones have done with todays equipment. Even training methods. People really underestimate the power of video and computer technology and how it has helped people "perfect" a swing. Who knows how dominant an older player might have been or on the flip side, how dominant a rival may have been that was just missing that little something extra.

Quoted for Truth. I'd love to see what the Golden Bear would have been in his prime with today's technology.
 
This may be a bit of a cop out on my end, but, it's really hard to pick one. I think each one was great in their respective time, but, to say "Greatest, it's really hard to compare. What would tiger do with cast iron irons and wooden shafts. What would Bobby Jones have done with todays equipment. Even training methods. People really underestimate the power of video and computer technology and how it has helped people "perfect" a swing. Who knows how dominant an older player might have been or on the flip side, how dominant a rival may have been that was just missing that little something extra.

I really don't follow golf that closely. I watch here and there. I know names and I play. So, if I had to pick. I'd say Tiger. The guy really is amazing to watch and to be honest, I never really got to watch anyone else.
I agree...if Bobby played today with today's technology, he would be just as good as Eldrick is, and the Golden Bear was.
 
I'm an old dude and have followed golf for a very long time. I can't speak to Bobby Jones, and oh my God did I ever love Nicklaus - but Tiger is a once in a generation athlete - playing golf. And the truth is, I'm old school enough that I didn't like him when he hit the tour. Taking a Nike endorsement when he's partially asian and african-american - the very people that Nike takes advantage of - I held it against him. But watching what he does, for me, I can't imagine choosing anyone else. He's won me over, and that's not an easy thing to do.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron