This time it's different

Jun 11, 2010
169
11
18
Urbandale, IA
Iowa State opens the season at 2 - 0 for just the 7th time since entering the Big 12. Those fast starts led to bowls in three seasons but two four win seasons, and in one season (2003) the Cyclones didn't win another game.

So which path will these Cyclones take? Let's take a look at an admittedly small sample size of information to make a best guess:

Paul Rhoads got his signature win early in 2011, winning his first non-conference regular season game against a BCS AQ school. He'll have another crack next week at UConn in what looks to be a winnable game against a program looking for leadership (three QBs played for first year head coach Paul Pasqualoni). CPR also is enjoying the first 2 - 0 start of his brief career. His postgame shout out to the fans and the band continue to add to his legend and are endearing him to an ever widening fanbase.

Steele Jantz put together an entire game, proving that that last 8 minutes of the UNI game weren't a fluke. At the end of the Iowa game he was drawing completely unfair comparisons to legendary quarterbacks. We'll know just how good he is soon enough, but he's just the 3rd ISU QB to start their ISU career 2 - 0 in the last decade, and neither Austin Flynn (UNI, Ohio) or Austin Arnaud (South Dakota State, Kent State) beat teams anywhere near the caliber that Jantz has already put away. He's put together back-to-back come from behind victories for a program where you can literally count them on your hands. This was just Iowa State's SECOND overtime victory in school history. The 4th quarter, once the enemy of Cyclone fans everywhere, has suddenly become "our time."

7 turnovers (and a -5 turnover margin), 18 penalties, and two missed field goals rarely result in wins for any team, regardless of the talent on the field. This team has made far more mistakes than either opponent yet has still found a way to win. Luckily those mistakes are unlikely to continue at this pace, and the silver lining is that this team has now faced adversity and come out on top. Unlike the Cyclone teams of the past, this team isn't afraid to have to make plays to win the game. They know what it takes and how to do it. That will definitely factor in during conference play.

Iowa State does not have a storied history of football success. In nearly 120 years of playing, we've averaged 4 wins per season. Our all-time leader in coaching wins (McCarney, 56) would be surpassed in 6 seasons by top programs. We've qualified to play in 10 bowl games, but nearly all of those have come in the expanded bowl season era. But successful programs start somewhere, and despite all of the disadvantages that make a logical person say it can't happen in Ames, you've got someone like Paul Rhoads that says "unacceptable."

CPR's teams have improved each year, and while he was cautiously optimistic before the season, he did his best to temper fan expectations. With so many new variables this season, how could you predict what we would see on game day? The end result so far is a team that has taken on the personality of their most dynamic offensive player, a defense that can be counted on to keep the game within reach, and aside from missed field goals that have haunted the program forever, a very solid special teams unit (Mahoney's deep kickoffs, Lenz and Shontrelle with great returns, and Kirby Van Der Kamp likely to kick on Sundays).

Because of these factors, I now see this Iowa State team winning 7 games and qualifying for a bowl in 2011. I said to start the season that if we could start 2 - 0 that we'd have a great chance to be 4 - 0. I see us winning by 10 in Storrs next weekend and then beating Texas in Ames by 4 in a game that likely won't surprise as many people as it should.

Road games against strong Baylor and Missouri teams will be tough tests, but I see the Cyclones going 1 - 1.

The brutal stretch to close the season has some relief with the two Kansas schools providing the final two wins of the season. I see one close game with A&M, OSU, OU and Tech, but I don't see us winning any of those games.

Thanks to the Cyclone football team for providing two great games. I'm looking forward to the rest of the season and expect to see more special performances!
 
Last edited:
Hard to tell exactly from this game....we dominated Iowa, yet almost gave the game away on silly mistakes. I think we are definitely better than the past few years, but I think Iowa is just simply not that good.
 
Hard to tell exactly from this game....we dominated Iowa, yet almost gave the game away on silly mistakes. I think we are definitely better than the past few years, but I think Iowa is just simply not that good.

+1

Wishing we had Iowa's schedule unstead of our slate... then I'd feel real confident. Still see us getting to a bowl game, but realistically seems like we could end up anywhere from 4-8 wins.
 
Iowa State opens the season at 2 - 0 for just the 7th time since entering the Big 12. Those fast starts led to bowls in three seasons but two four win seasons, and in one season (2003) the Cyclones didn't win another game.

I haven't read the rest of your post, but noticed this. The Cyclones also started 2-0 in 2008, and didn't win another game.
 
Don't jump the gun yet. Who knows what we will end up at, but this is a great start :)

It's definitely early to be thinking about a bowl when you've just beaten an FCS team by a single point and an unranked Iowa team at home. But, if there's anything that CPR wants is for Cyclone Nation to think big. Our schedule looked daunting two weeks ago. Now it looks much less so. Just trying to get some conversations going.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crash_zone
Because of these factors, I now see this Iowa State team winning 7 games and qualifying for a bowl in 2011. I said to start the season that if we could start 2 - 0 that we'd have a great chance to be 4 - 0. I see us winning by 10 in Storrs next weekend and then beating Texas in Ames by 4 in a game that likely won't surprise as many people as it should.

Road games against strong Baylor and Missouri teams will be tough tests, but I see the Cyclones going 1 - 1.

The brutal stretch to close the season has some relief with the two Kansas schools providing the final two wins of the season. I see one close game with A&M, OSU, OU and Tech, but I don't see us winning any of those games.

Thanks to the Cyclone football team for providing two great games. I'm looking forward to the rest of the season and expect to see more special performances!
I had predicted 7 wins before the season as well, though I had predicted the Iowa game to be a loss. I had predicted wins over:

UNI
UConn
Baylor
Kansas
Kansas State
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

No reason why we shouldn't be able to get to at least 6 wins now, as we better get wins over UConn, Baylor, Kansas, and Kansas State to get to 6.
 
I had predicted 7 wins before the season as well, though I had predicted the Iowa game to be a loss. I had predicted wins over:

UNI
UConn
Baylor
Kansas
Kansas State
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

No reason why we shouldn't be able to get to at least 6 wins now, as we better get wins over UConn, Baylor, Kansas, and Kansas State to get to 6.

If we learned anything the last two years in Conference Play, its that Rhoads and Co will get one no one was expecting, with Iowa now in the Win Column (doesn't count as unexpected), UConn is critical, after that I agree 6 wins should be attainable, 7-8 wins would be pheonominal.

We are watching the transformation of a team that most say "nice Coach" but is "too outmanned to make any real noise" to a team that will beat you on the field based on the quality of play and coaching. I expect a few more bumps before we get there, but lets remember Coach said we would be celebrating a Conference Championship one day after the big Nebraska win. Beating Iowa in 3 OT's playing straight up and not taking any chances shows real improvement. Sure makes up for the Nebraska loss last year. Don't know which games they will be, but I predict beating Iowa will be an after thought of what this team accomplishes this year
 
I could definitely see us winning anywhere from 5-8 games this year. It just depends on how we finish down the stretch. We can beat UCONN, Texas, Mizzou, Tech, KU, and Kstate, no doubt in my mind.
 
I had predicted 7 wins before the season as well, though I had predicted the Iowa game to be a loss. I had predicted wins over:

UNI
UConn
Baylor
Kansas
Kansas State
Texas A&M
Texas Tech

No reason why we shouldn't be able to get to at least 6 wins now, as we better get wins over UConn, Baylor, Kansas, and Kansas State to get to 6.

Have you been paying attention to Baylor so far? Beating them this year is going to be really tough.

The main thing this team needs to do now is forget about Iowa and make sure they get focused on UConn. We can't afford a let down after a nice W against our rivals.
 
Have you been paying attention to Baylor so far? Beating them this year is going to be really tough.

The main thing this team needs to do now is forget about Iowa and make sure they get focused on UConn. We can't afford a let down after a nice W against our rivals.
I sure have. Did you see that they gave up 48 points in their first game of the season? That tells me they're beatable, and they won't win many ball games this year, if they continue to give up that many points in a single game.
 
Paul Rhoads got his signature win early in 2011, winning his first non-conference regular season game against a BCS AQ school.

Way way way too early to call this a signature win. It sure means a lot to our team and fans, but if Iowa finishes 5-7, it's not a signature win. Wins over teams like Texas A&M, Oklahoma, and Oklahoma State all have the potential to be much more meaningful and truly be signature wins for the season.
 
I agree that Friday is critical, a very winnable game. I see this season coming down to how we play on the road. If we step up and grab a couple conference road games, we will have one heck of a season. 5-8 wins is where I see us, I hope I'm low.

One game note, I don't remember us sending any blitzes yesterday, used our front four. We didn't get any sacks, but they pressured him just enough to change a few passes. We have great lb's and corners and they seemed to keep most passes in front of them.
 
Many of our questions will be answered on Friday. UConn is one of our most winnable remaining games. This will tell us whether Iowa was a fluke or not in all likelihood.

UConn, K-State, KU, TTech and Texas appear to be our best chances. We need to win 4 of those and pick up an upset along the way.

Too bad we're not playing in the Big 10 this season.
 
It would be just like my personal "Cyclone fate" (though I think this is true enough for our football teams in general) for the team to explode and go 8-4 with some nice "upsets" over programs like Texas, TAMU, and OSU the year after I am finally no longer able to watch it all up-close and in-person. Eh, while I'm at it, why not 10-2 and threatening for a Big XII title and BCS game right down to the last weeks? Or just go Tom Berenger on the thing?

Whatever. Go State! Make this season something special while we still have LJ and Jantz!
 
Have you been paying attention to Baylor so far? Beating them this year is going to be really tough.

The main thing this team needs to do now is forget about Iowa and make sure they get focused on UConn. We can't afford a let down after a nice W against our rivals.

I think with our defense trying to catch Steele every day in practice that we'll be as prepared for Robert Griffin as anyone in the conference. I'm not predicting a win, but I don't see a blowout either. Mizzou is probably a better chance for a road win.
 
Way way way too early to call this a signature win. It sure means a lot to our team and fans, but if Iowa finishes 5-7, it's not a signature win. Wins over teams like Texas A&M, Oklahoma, and Oklahoma State all have the potential to be much more meaningful and truly be signature wins for the season.

Let's just call it his first upset of the season then. McCarney and Chizik rarely beat teams that they weren't supposed to, and CPR has shown that he can do that at least once a season. Realistically Iowa is the 7th or 8th best team we'll play this year so beating them doesn't guarantee future success, but I think it's the way that we won that sets this team apart early in the season.
 
I agree that Friday is critical, a very winnable game. I see this season coming down to how we play on the road. If we step up and grab a couple conference road games, we will have one heck of a season. 5-8 wins is where I see us, I hope I'm low.

One game note, I don't remember us sending any blitzes yesterday, used our front four. We didn't get any sacks, but they pressured him just enough to change a few passes. We have great lb's and corners and they seemed to keep most passes in front of them.

The "bend don't break" defense works well when we can force mistakes/turnovers (haven't done that) and can score consistently on offense (saw that in the 2nd half of Iowa). All you can ask for is to improve every game, and that's what ISU has done in it's first two games. We could easily be 0 - 2, but we're 2 - 0 and are now getting some team chemistry and a healthy dose of confidence.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron