NFL: Pick One
- Thread starter coachdags
- Start date
All time? or just current players?
If we are talking current players, I say Brady, although I want to say P. Manning.
All time? Much as I hate to say it, Joe Montana.
EDIT: Guess I didn't wait for the poll. Hate it when I am posting a poll and that happens.
If we are talking current players, I say Brady, although I want to say P. Manning.
All time? Much as I hate to say it, Joe Montana.
EDIT: Guess I didn't wait for the poll. Hate it when I am posting a poll and that happens.
I added your boy he is worthy of consideration, he has a couple of rings...:wink:
Tony Romo
sorry, we do not need a place kick holder.....ouch...:wink:
He also got that second ring by taking his team down the field in the final minutes.
Manning is the best at preparation but has choked more times than not in his career
That leaves us with Favre or Brady. Favre has looked better so far this year and if we are going off this year you say him.
Brees? Great QB but he hasn't won anything....ever.
That leaves us with Favre or Brady. Favre has looked better so far this year and if we are going off this year you say him.
Brees? Great QB but he hasn't won anything....ever.
Man this is so close. I don't think you could go wrong with any of the 5, seriously.
Picking one, I go with P.Manning. I think no one else in the game can surgically dissect a defense with such precision and ease as he does. This season just really proves that, as he is doing it with guys most felt should not be starting for them. Or at least, would struggle early on in their new roles.
Picking one, I go with P.Manning. I think no one else in the game can surgically dissect a defense with such precision and ease as he does. This season just really proves that, as he is doing it with guys most felt should not be starting for them. Or at least, would struggle early on in their new roles.
Manning and its not even close. He doesn't care who is WR's are, he just picks up where he left off last year. The most impressive thing about Peyton is that he is doing it without a running game.
I don't think we're talking about playoffs. We're talking about who could win you a game right now.
Or as another coach once put it...
YouTube - Playoffs??? The Sound Byte
Playoff records for the past 3 years...
B.Roethlisberger - 2007 (0-1), 2008 (3-0) - 3-1
P.Manning - 2006 (4-0), 2007 (0-1), 2008 (0-1) - 4-2
T.Brady - 2006 (2-1), 2007 (2-1) - 4-2
B.Favre - 2007 (1-1) - 1-1
D.Brees - 2006 (1-1) - 1-1
Pro-Football-Reference.com - Pro Football Statistics and History
B.Roethlisberger - 2007 (0-1), 2008 (3-0) - 3-1
P.Manning - 2006 (4-0), 2007 (0-1), 2008 (0-1) - 4-2
T.Brady - 2006 (2-1), 2007 (2-1) - 4-2
B.Favre - 2007 (1-1) - 1-1
D.Brees - 2006 (1-1) - 1-1
Pro-Football-Reference.com - Pro Football Statistics and History
Ordinarily I'd go with Peyton Manning, but since "this season" is the stated qualifier, I'd have to go with Drew Brees. I mean, he only got done torching one of the best defenses in the league Sunday against the Giants, and showed he could win "grind-out" games against the Jets.
you just wanted to use that video
and I figure if you're talking about 1 game then the Playoffs are a good reference for success in pressure, single elim, games.
Manning will easily be the greatest statistical QB of all time, but unfortunately he goes "0-1" in the playoffs way too much to be the greatest Clutch QB of all time.