Personal foul roughing the passer?

Day's helmet came partially off. I'm sure that's why it was called. If his helmet was firmly on I don't think a flag is thrown.
I was wondering this too. Hit was timed well and clean, the helmet came off just because of the impact. Should have discussed and picked up the flag
 
The rules were put in place to protect the players, I get that, but it's now tilted too far in the name of safety that its effecting the game. We have gone from helmet to helmet, now to any blow above the shoulders to the head and neck is a penalty and possible ejection from the game.

We need to go back to it has to be obvious to everyone in the stadium to be thrown out of the game. Direct full force helmet to helmet or hitting a defenseless receiver stretching out to catch the ball or when the ball is by them. Take out the dirty play, otherwise it's a 5 yard add on penalty and keep the game going.

In the Rutgers/NW game was a perfect example, the QB was running, and at the last second, started to slide, the Rutgers player tried to avoid hitting him by diving over but his shoulder did have contact with the QB's head on the side. Flag was thrown, they are debating what it should be called in the booth, and they decided the player should not be ejected for the play.
My problem is they completely ignore the most egregious acts that are done by offensive players. Baylor’s TE Sims from a couple years ago would lower his head and lead with the crown with being tackled all the time. Whether it’s instinct or bad intent, it doesn’t matter. It’s avoidable. By the letter and spirit of the law it should’ve been targeting, but it’s not even a consideration.
 
My problem is they completely ignore the most egregious acts that are done by offensive players. Baylor’s TE Sims from a couple years ago would lower his head and lead with the crown with being tackled all the time. Whether it’s instinct or bad intent, it doesn’t matter. It’s avoidable. By the letter and spirit of the law it should’ve been targeting, but it’s not even a consideration.
Purdys last year I was at OU and saw their DE twice leave his feet and go helmet to helmet on Brock and no call. It’s the south teams that get extra leeway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: isutrevman

Help Support Us

Become a patron