NFL: Colston or Cotchery

[tman24]

I can't decide who to start. Colston is coming off a bye after his first week back from an injury playing at Atlanta. Cotchery has been up and down pointwise all season and is playing against St Louis at home. Both seem unpredictable. What does everyone else think?

 

[CRcyclone6]

i have Colston and i know he's been hurt, but he has been a big disappointment in the games he's played in since the injury. That's a tough choice. I would think he would break out sooner or later. Who else do you have? I'm glad i have Boldin and Jennings to start in-front of Colston.

 

[cmoneyr]

I have Cotchery and I start him about every week, he's had some good weeks and some below average weeks, but he always atleast gets balls thrown his way.

 

[Cardinal&Gold11]

I would go with Colston, but that's just my gut feeling. I think he's gonna have a breakout week

 

[tman24]

In my league we have 1 rb 1 wr and 1wr/rb option. I have b marshall in for the wr and m lynch at rb my others are on bye so it is really just between cotchery or colston. i am leaning more towards cotchery because he does always get the ball and he is at home.

 

[tman24]

I would go with Colston, but that's just my gut feeling. I think he's gonna have a breakout week

and that is what i am debating. i am playing the number 1 guy in the league so i need every point out of every guy.

 

[StormnClone58]

colston .... esp if its a ppr league ... brees has been tearing it up this year and nothing like having his #1 wr back ...

 

[CRcyclone6]

go with Cotchery. you are right about him atleast getting a few pts every week. either way, you will probably be wrong. thats what i've learned in fantasy football. when it comes to tough choices, the other guy will score more pts that week.

 

[tman24]

added a poll. whoever is ahead by sunday morning gets the start. i really hope it doesnt end in a tie.

 

[mj4cy]

Colston is more consistent. Cotchery is hit or miss.

 

[cloneu]

I would start Cotchery. I love Colston though, I had him his rookie year and he was listed as TE/WR so I could always use him as my TE.

 

[Drizzle]

I would say Cotchery, Favre will most likely go off sometime soon with a big game.. He has a tendency to do that 2-3 times a year.. Also, Cotch has been steady each week WITHOUT a TD reception the last 5 games I think.. I think he'll get one this weekend, JMO..

 

[Ocho]

I wouldnt touch anyone coming off an injury. Colston is a stud but Brees has been successful w/out him, he can throw to anyone At least w/ the Jets you have a 50/50 chance; either Coles or Cotch will have a good game. Colston plays against ATL and their defense isnt to bad. Cotchery plays against STL and they are aweful.