Hy-Vee's weirdest business decision yet?

I'm not sure that I would put self-checkout on the list of weird Hy-Vee business decisions. A lot of retailers are considering self-checkout to be a failed experiment and are scaling it back in favor of human cashiers. Even unintentional theft is a problem with self-checkout because the process is so janky, to say nothing of the opportunity for intentional theft.
I find it interesting that Hy Vee and Walmart posts two or three of its workers in the self checkout areas. Doesn’t that defeat the purpose?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: SEIOWA CLONE
I find it interesting that Hy Vee and Walmart posts two or three of its workers in the self checkout areas. Doesn’t that defeat the purpose?

Not that I pay that attention that closely, but I think the ones I've seen are staffed with one or two people for ~6 self-checkout units. I can't imagine not needing at least one employee, both for loss prevention and helping customers.

Even if one employee can only manage two self-checkout units, that's still one employee you aren't paying.
 
Yeah, this is another bizarre one. HyVees are mostly located in smaller towns and suburbs around the midwest. Not typically the neighborhoods where I feel like a grocery store has a need for armed security. No better way to make me feel that helpful smile in every isle vibe than an overweight security guard walking around looking like they are trying to live out their long lost Seal Team Six fantasy.
Former colleague’s husband is a HyVee manager, and he said the biggest thieves are soccer moms.
 
I find it interesting that Hy Vee and Walmart posts two or three of its workers in the self checkout areas. Doesn’t that defeat the purpose?
I've only seen one at Hy-Vee for 6 checkout spots. Compared to the conventional checkout where you have at least one employee per customer, and usually 2 counting the bagger, that's a hell of a lot less employees per customer at self check out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wxman1
Not that I pay that attention that closely, but I think the ones I've seen are staffed with one or two people for ~6 self-checkout units. I can't imagine not needing at least one employee, both for loss prevention and helping customers.

Even if one employee can only manage two self-checkout units, that's still one employee you aren't paying.

Honestly my biggest annoyance with self checkout isn't the scanning its the bagging. From having to do both jobs simultaneously to having to deal with tiny bagging areas that you can't move stuff from that many stores have, its just a hassle.

I actually like the larger hyvee ones that you self-scan but then things roll down to a bagger at the end of the register. Probably limits (intentional) theft too as theres an employee right there. And from their perspective, if they have a couple of those that still cuts down on the number of required employees. What used to take 3-4 employees might only take 1-2.
 
  • Winner
  • Agree
Reactions: Kinch and nrg4isu
I'm not sure that I would put self-checkout on the list of weird Hy-Vee business decisions. A lot of retailers are considering self-checkout to be a failed experiment and are scaling it back in favor of human cashiers. Even unintentional theft is a problem with self-checkout because the process is so janky, to say nothing of the opportunity for intentional theft.
Probably also has to do with most people not being intelligent enough to efficiently check their own groceries. I am always amazed at how long people stand there and struggle. It is one of the few things in the world that makes me feel intelligent (joking, kind of) after I watch someone check out for 10 minutes and then it takes me 30 seconds. If they do go away I will need something to replace it or my self esteem is going to crater
 
  • Like
Reactions: isufbcurt
Probably also has to do with most people not being intelligent enough to efficiently check their own groceries. I am always amazed at how long people stand there and struggle. It is one of the few things in the world that makes me feel intelligent (joking, kind of) after I watch someone check out for 10 minutes and then it takes me 30 seconds. If they do go away I will need something to replace it or my self esteem is going to crater
i don't see how you can realistically do that unless your cart is only party packs of ramen and busch light.
 
i don't see how you can realistically do that unless your cart is only party packs of ramen and busch light.
To be fair I usually don’t get much produce from hyvee, most of that I get from Aldi so it’s kinda BS but I still feel like a majority of people are just awful at using the self checkout (the point about the bagging space being too small is definitely valid though)

Also to be clear I don’t think people are actually stupid I was mostly saying that in jest I think it’s just a weird skill of mine. And hyvees POS system is honestly kind of laggy to begin with IMO
 
Last edited:
I've only seen one at Hy-Vee for 6 checkout spots. Compared to the conventional checkout where you have at least one employee per customer, and usually 2 counting the bagger, that's a hell of a lot less employees per customer at self check out.
That's a hell of a lot of hok fans out of a job too.
 
For sure. Produce alone could cause enough unintentional loss to scale back self-checkout
That's not just a self checkout problem. I can't count the number of times I have been at a register and the person working doesn't know what the product, product code, or price is and just ring it in as .99 or sometimes ask me if I remember the price or know what the produce is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kinch
I'm not sure that I would put self-checkout on the list of weird Hy-Vee business decisions. A lot of retailers are considering self-checkout to be a failed experiment and are scaling it back in favor of human cashiers. Even unintentional theft is a problem with self-checkout because the process is so janky, to say nothing of the opportunity for intentional theft.

Unintentional theft from the shoppers to the huge corporations is a massive problem too, I’m sure I’ve caught hundreds of dollars in mistakes over the years…when every checkout started having a screen it was a game changer for the consumer. If a checkout person goes at light speed they’re going to have to wait a minute while I check for errors. I was at Trader Joe’s a few weeks ago and caught $4 difference from shelf signage on a bottle of olive oil. The guy even tried to argue with me the sign was wrong and I simply said I don’t want it then they gave me the $4 but with a warning for next time as if their mistake was me pulling a fast one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: I@ST1
Unintentional theft from the shoppers to the huge corporations is a massive problem too, I’m sure I’ve caught hundreds of dollars in mistakes over the years…when every checkout started having a screen it was a game changer for the consumer. If a checkout person goes at light speed they’re going to have to wait a minute while I check for errors. I was at Trader Joe’s a few weeks ago and caught $4 difference from shelf signage on a bottle of olive oil. The guy even tried to argue with me the sign was wrong and I simply said I don’t want it then they gave me the $4 but with a warning for next time as if their mistake was me pulling a fast one.
Funny enough the other weekend we went to the closest HyVee (which holy **** their prices are ridiculous) and were checking out and there were 2 different items that rang up different from what their posted signs were. Wasn't a lot only a couple $ but I caught it, they happily changed it to the right amount bu your post got me to thinking about how many people wouldn't have caught it because they were blazing through scanning items.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyclone06
Funny enough the other weekend we went to the closest HyVee (which holy **** their prices are ridiculous) and were checking out and there were 2 different items that rang up different from what their posted signs were. Wasn't a lot only a couple $ but I caught it, they happily changed it to the right amount bu your post got me to thinking about how many people wouldn't have caught it because they were blazing through scanning items.
Doubt that would get caught at regular checkout either.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron