Teams
Forum List
Toggle sidebar

Trent Condon

NorthCyd said:
This debate was fun for a while because it was about an Iowa loss, but seriously. How long can you people argue the same points over and over and over again? Its not even hawk fans you are debating with. It's other ISU fans. Its been 5 days. Don't you think it's time to move on?
Click to expand...

I’d like to debate your post on the merits
 
GMackey32 said:
This isn't a great argument when Donovan McNabb didn't know you could tie even after being in the league for 10 years at that point.

By the letter of the rule, it was the correct call.
Click to expand...

Yeah, sorry, a QB who hasn't been in college for 20 years isn't who I'm going to for rule advice on an NCAA punt return. And while McAfee was at least on the punt team (15+ years ago for college), that doesn't mean he knows every rule for the return team. His rant on this included multiple things that weren't factual to this situation anyway (like the ranting about it not being a fair catch signal - no ****, nobody said it was!).
 
  • Like
  • Winner
  • Dumb
Reactions: JimmyChitwood, CyDude16, Cyclonscin and 3 others
madguy30 said:
How was it a bad call?

If you wave your arms, it's a dead ball and all scoring plays are reviewable.

I'm sorry your team lost again but if you're struggling this much with that, it would probably be a good idea to skip ISU's basketball season because they're going to lose some games, not win the conference title even if they win a few early, and we've all seen you struggle and live outside reality with that concept.
Click to expand...
I already explained in detail how bad of a call it was 4 days ago, I dont have time argue about it anymore.

Only reason 90% of you guys on here think it was the correct call is because of the team it involved.

Go watch the field level view of it, it was absolutely egregious to make that call in that situation based on his movements. End of story.
 
  • Dumb
  • Disagree
  • Optimistic
Reactions: Carlisle Clone, flycy, wenkeej and 5 others
NoCreativity said:
I already explained in detail how bad of a call it was 4 days ago, I dont have time argue about it anymore.

Only reason 90% of you guys on here think it was the correct call is because of the team it involved.

Go watch the field level view of it, it was absolutely egregious to make that call in that situation based on his movements. End of story.
Click to expand...
You kind of gave away the game here. So its okay to make that call when its not in the situation? Wouldn't that be selectively applying the rules?
 
  • Like
Reactions: CyDude16
GMackey32 said:
This isn't a great argument when Donovan McNabb didn't know you could tie even after being in the league for 10 years at that point.

By the letter of the rule, it was the correct call.
Click to expand...
One moron 15 years ago didn't know a rule so that means no NFL players should give their expertise? Nice one.
 
NoCreativity said:
I already explained in detail how bad of a call it was 4 days ago, I dont have time argue about it anymore.

Only reason 90% of you guys on here think it was the correct call is because of the team it involved.

Go watch the field level view of it, it was absolutely egregious to make that call in that situation based on his movements. End of story.
Click to expand...

Did he wave his left arm?

Yes or no?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyChitwood, CyDude16 and GMackey32
NoCreativity said:
Aaron Rodgers, Pat McAfee and those guys who spent years in the NFL don't know football rules?

Let's cut the *****, there are only 2 fanbases that think it was a good call. One of the them has the biggest d-bag coach in college football and I wonder who the other is?

I saw even Chris Williams tweeting about.
Click to expand...

GMackey32 said:
This isn't a great argument when Donovan McNabb didn't know you could tie even after being in the league for 10 years at that point.

By the letter of the rule, it was the correct call.
Click to expand...

NoCreativity said:
One moron 15 years ago didn't know a rule so that means no NFL players should give their expertise? Nice one.
Click to expand...
Nice strawman. I never said that. More alluding to the fact that just because they played in the NFL doesn't necessarily make them experts like you alluded to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyChitwood
madguy30 said:
Are you saying a ref didn't have a view of it on the field?

Should we make calls based on an on the field view?

Did he wave his arm? Yes or no? Why is that so hard to answer?
Click to expand...
You exactly proved my point. No refs with a view from down on the field called absolutely anything.

I hate to break the bad news to you, but you are in about the 1% minority of people in this country who think it was a good call.
 
  • Haha
  • Dumb
  • Disagree
Reactions: Carlisle Clone, flycy, Tailg8er and 3 others
NoCreativity said:
You exactly proved my point. No refs with a view from down on the field called absolutely anything.

I hate to break the bad news to you, but you are in about the 1% minority of people in this country who think it was a good call.
Click to expand...

So it doesn't happen occasionally where a play occurs and then gets reversed upon further review?

Do you think they should review all scoring plays?

Did he wave his left arm or not?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Help Support Us

Become a patron
Top Bottom